Does Apple Cause Cold And Cough

Question

I’ve been eating apples regularly because they’re easy to include in my meals, and I’ve always thought of them as a healthy option. Recently, though, someone told me that apples might not be good if you’re prone to cold and cough. This left me wondering: does apple cause cold and cough, or is it just a myth?

From what I understand, apples are rich in vitamins and fiber, and they’re supposed to strengthen the immune system. How, then, could they potentially cause cold and cough? Could it have something to do with the fact that apples are considered cooling in nature according to Ayurveda? Does this cooling effect aggravate conditions like mucus production or throat irritation, especially in colder weather?

I’m also curious if the way apples are eaten makes a difference. For instance, does apple cause cold and cough more if it’s eaten raw versus cooked? I often eat apples raw or add them to smoothies. Would cooking the apple, like in stews or desserts, reduce any potential issues?

Timing might also play a role. Does eating apples in the evening or at night increase the risk of developing cold and cough? I’ve read that certain foods should be avoided later in the day because they’re harder to digest or might create imbalances. Does this apply to apples as well?

Another thought is whether the type of apple matters. I usually eat red apples, but does apple cause cold and cough more if it’s a green variety, which tends to be more acidic? Are there any specific varieties of apples that are better for people with a sensitive respiratory system?

Lastly, if apples can indeed cause cold and cough, are there ways to counteract this? For example, could adding warming spices like cinnamon or ginger to apple dishes balance out their cooling effect? If anyone has experienced this or has advice on how to consume apples safely while avoiding cold and cough, I’d appreciate your input.

Dr Sujal Patil · Accepted Answer

In Ayurveda, apples are considered to have a cooling effect on the body, which can increase mucus production and aggravate conditions like cold and cough, particularly if you're already prone to these issues or if you consume them in cold weather. The cooling nature of apples may cause discomfort in the throat or worsen congestion, especially if eaten raw. This is why some people suggest avoiding apples if you're susceptible to respiratory issues.

To minimize these effects, cooking apples (e.g., in stews or with warming spices like cinnamon or ginger) can help balance their cooling nature. These warming spices counteract the cooling effects and make apples easier on the respiratory system. Eating apples earlier in the day might also be better since digestion tends to be stronger in the morning and afternoon, reducing the likelihood of any imbalances.

Regarding apple varieties, the green apple (more acidic) might be slightly harsher on the stomach and respiratory system than red apples, but it’s not a major issue for everyone. If you’re particularly sensitive, red apples are generally gentler.

In conclusion, apples don't cause cold and cough for everyone, but if you're sensitive or already experiencing respiratory issues, it may help to adjust how and when you eat them, incorporating warming spices or cooking them.

Dr. Ayush Varma · Answer

Apples causing cold and cough is rather a myth than a solid fact. But you're right, Ayurveda views them as cooling, potentially leading to imbalances in some individuals, especially those with a kapha prakriti — likely to get more mucus production and respiratory issues. But it's not like apples have a secret vendetta against your wellness. Most people don’t face trouble with apples boosting their cold and cough, unless some specific imbalance exists.

You’re spot on about the cooling nature — it’s less about apples “causing” the problem, and more about them possibly aggravating a pre-existing condition. Imagine having a tendency towards kapha imbalance during winter, with increased mucus production. The cooling nature might just exacerbate that. Eating them alongside warming spices like cinnamon, ginger? That's actually a brilliant counterbalance! These can help with digestion and reduce kapha accumulation.

Now, eating raw apples vs cooked? Cooked apples, like in a warm, cozy stew, could be less aggravating. Cooking can transform how the body processes them, warming up those qualities and making them more digestible for some. That especially helps if eaten in the evening when your digestive fire (agni) might naturally wind down.

Timing’s important too. You’ve got it; evening meals should be lighter. The heaviness of a raw apple at night could be a bit too much for some digestive tracts, potentially leading to kapha imbalances. Swapping it for a warm apple dish or a sprinkle of cinnamon if you insist on a night snack might just do the trick.

Green vs red apples? The acidity in green apples adds another layer of complexity but not necessarily about cold and cough directly. It's very individual — depending if acidity aggravates your personal constitution or not.

If cold and cough is genuinely a recurring concern, keeping your digestive strength up is critical — warm herbal teas, like tulsi or ginger, can support your respiratory tract. Do consider your dosha and season when deciding how to enjoy apples. Enjoying them warm, and with those spices can harmonize any cooling effect, making them a delightful, safe addition. Does this help quench some curiosity?

Does Apple Cause Cold And Cough - #6427

Doctors’ responses

About our doctors

Related questions

Popular questions

Doctors online

Latest reviews