Ask Ayurveda

FREE! Ask Ayurvedic Doctors 24/7

Get expert answers from certified doctors anytime

Fast responses
1000+ verified doctors
Ear, Nose, and Throat Disorders
Question #5669
1 year ago
1,035

Fish Treatment For Asthma - #5669

Bella
FREE

I’ve been dealing with asthma for most of my life, and someone recently told me about a fish treatment for asthma that’s popular in India. I’m curious about what this treatment involves and how it’s supposed to work. Is this fish treatment for asthma a recognized Ayurvedic practice, or is it more of a traditional remedy? From what I’ve read, it seems like live fish are used, and they’re given with a specific herbal paste. Is this fish treatment for asthma safe, and has it been proven to help people with chronic asthma? I’m worried about whether it’s hygienic and if there are any risks, especially with infections or allergies. My asthma is usually triggered by seasonal changes and dust. Could the fish treatment for asthma address these triggers, or does it work differently? I’ve tried inhalers and Western medications, but I don’t like relying on them all the time. Does this treatment provide long-term relief or just temporary improvement? Also, is the fish treatment for asthma suitable for children? I have a 7-year-old nephew who also has asthma, and his parents are considering this treatment. If anyone has undergone this fish treatment for asthma, please share your experience. Did it make a noticeable difference?

Question is closed
Writing an explanation of your symptoms through Ayurveda...
Analyzing through Ayurvedic framework0%

Doctors' responses

The fish treatment for asthma you’re referring to is likely part of traditional or folk remedies found in certain regions of India, but it is not a widely recognized Ayurvedic practice. The treatment typically involves placing live fish on specific points of the body or in contact with the skin, sometimes combined with herbal pastes or oils. The fish, often said to have healing properties, are believed to help stimulate circulation and relieve symptoms of asthma by improving respiratory function. However, there are concerns about the safety and hygiene of this practice, particularly regarding the potential for infections or allergic reactions, as the fish may carry bacteria or other pathogens.

Regarding asthma triggers like dust or seasonal changes, while there is anecdotal evidence suggesting that certain natural therapies can help with respiratory conditions, this fish treatment has not been scientifically proven to provide long-term relief for asthma. Western medicine, including inhalers and medications, typically remains the most reliable treatment for chronic asthma, as they are designed to manage symptoms and prevent attacks effectively.

For children, such as your 7-year-old nephew, it is important to be cautious. Children with asthma should consult with a pediatrician before trying alternative treatments, especially ones that involve potential allergens or infections. If anyone has personal experience with this fish treatment, it would be helpful to hear whether it led to noticeable improvements and how it was performed safely.

13374 answered questions
39% best answers
Accepted response

0 replies

The “fish treatment” for asthma that you’re referring to is likely a traditional remedy practiced in certain regions of India, particularly in Kerala, and is not widely recognized in mainstream Ayurvedic medicine. This treatment involves the use of live fish, which are sometimes applied to specific parts of the body, often along with herbal pastes, as a part of a larger healing or detoxification process. This practice is rooted in folk medicine and is considered part of the more traditional, localized practices rather than a well-documented Ayurvedic treatment.

Regarding safety and efficacy, there are concerns you should consider before trying such a treatment. The treatment’s hygienic standards can be questionable, and there are potential risks, such as infections, allergies, or adverse reactions, especially for individuals with sensitive skin or respiratory conditions like asthma. It’s also important to note that live fish treatments have not been scientifically proven to provide long-term asthma relief, and the mechanisms behind such treatments are not well understood in the context of modern medical science.

Asthma is typically triggered by environmental factors such as dust, allergens, or seasonal changes. While some traditional remedies claim to help with respiratory issues, including asthma, their effectiveness is often anecdotal and varies from person to person. Modern treatments like inhalers and medications remain the most reliable for managing asthma symptoms.

For children, especially young ones like your nephew, it’s essential to be cautious. The treatment might be physically uncomfortable or distressing for children, and its safety is not well-documented. You should consult a pediatrician or an experienced Ayurvedic practitioner before considering any alternative treatments for asthma in children.

If you’re looking for more established Ayurvedic approaches to asthma, there are herbs like Tulsi (holy basil), Vasa, and Yashtimadhu that are known for their ability to support lung health and manage asthma symptoms. Pranayama (breathing exercises) and panchakarma (detoxification treatments) are also often recommended as part of an Ayurvedic approach to chronic respiratory issues.

In conclusion, while the fish treatment may be part of some traditional practices, it is not a widely recognized or scientifically validated remedy for asthma. You should approach it with caution, especially considering the potential risks involved. For effective asthma management, it’s better to rely on medically recognized treatments or consult an Ayurvedic practitioner for more targeted and safer remedies.

13597 answered questions
29% best answers

0 replies

Ah, I see where you’re coming from with those questions about this fish treatment. You’re probably talking about the Bathini Goud treatment, a popular ritual in India, especially Hyderabad. Yes, it involves swallowing a live murrel fish filled with a herbal paste, called “prasadam” by the followers. But it’s more of a traditional ritual, than a recognized Ayurveda remedy.

In terms of safety and efficacy, there isn’t scientific consens… because the effectiveness hasn’t been scientifically validated. Many families swear by it, reporting that it helps manage symptoms, but testimonials lack the solid research backing that standard medical treatments have. And, you’re right to worry about hygiene and allergies. Using live fish poses risk of infections or allergic reactions, especially if the fish isn’t handled properly.

Regarding your triggers like seasonal changes and dust, Ayurveda takes a different approach based on understanding your unique dosha composition (Vata, Pitta, Kapha) and addressing root causes. For asthma, it’s often tied to an imbalance in Kapha and sometimes Vata. Unlike the quick fix of an inhaler, Ayurvedic management may include diet modifications, herbal teas, regular exercise, and breathing techniques like pranayama for longer-term relief.

As for children, particularly your nephew, with Ayurveda or any traditional treatments, safety and specificity are key. Young children have different susceptibilities, and any treatment should prioritize a child-specific Ayurvedic approach, focusing on gentle, balanced interventions tailored to his constitution. I’d personally caution against treatments involving live fish for a kid.

So, while the fish treatment may be culturally rich and symbolically significant for some, I wouldn’t advise counting on it as a primary treatment for asthma. It’s always a good idea to consult with experienced Ayurvedic practitioner to curate a safe and effective treatment plan. And of course, always keep their pediatrician in the loop if considering alternative remedies for children.

12004 answered questions
27% best answers

0 replies

About our doctors

Only qualified ayurvedic doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service. You can check the qualification confirmation in the doctor's profile.


Seeking Ayurvedic Recommendations for Long-term Tinnitus
How to treat constant throat pain and nasal blockage with sinusitis?
Tingling Sensation in Ears While Eating
Severe Nasal Polyps and Heart Issues
Timeframe for Relief from Nasal Polyps with Ayurvedic Treatment
Hoarseness and Nasal Congestion Issues
How to treat hearing loss in an 81-year-old and can ear drops strengthen nerves?
How to treat a blocked ear after visiting a cold high altitude place?
How to treat throat infection with gas and acidity issues?
How to manage heavy nosebleeds from hereditary hemorrhagic telangiectasia?
What to do for eye discharge and mucus causing throat cough?
Is there a non-surgical treatment for my ear condition?
What is the treatment for sinus issues with pain in the head and throat?
Can I use Tribhuvan Ras for a runny left nose, and how should I take it?
Long-term Struggle with Nasal Polyps and Sinus Issues
Can I swallow or spit out Nasya oil?
What to do for ringing and warmth around the ears after high blood pressure treatment?
Persistent Crackling Sounds in Ears After Severe Cold
Diet Recommendations for My Daughter's Adenoid Enlargement
Is there a non-surgical treatment for my ear perforation?
Loss of Smell and Taste for 6 Years
What to do for persistent ear infection and pressure after treatment?
Best Medicine for Adenoids in My Child
Is surgery necessary for a childhood ear drum perforation or can Ayurveda help treat it?
Difficulty Swallowing After Eating Certain Lentils
Inflammation and Fullness in Ears
Experiencing Vertigo and Left Side Ear and Nose Pain
What is the best treatment for my husband's 60% hearing loss at age 67?
What to do if I hear a popping sound in my ear and feel lightheaded when holding my breath?
Heavy Head and Sinus Pressure for One Week
How to treat persistent nasal congestion and cough lasting 6 to 8 months?
What is the treatment for 60% hearing loss in a 10-year-old child?
What to do for daily sore throat and rough voice that gets choked while laughing?
Constant Whistling in Ears - Is There a Cure?
What to do for parotid swelling and dry mouth in a breastfeeding mother?
What to do for excessive body heat and sensitive throat with viral symptoms?
What to do for nasal allergy that causes blockage for 7 months without cold or cough?
How to treat tinnitus after ear injury and will it get better?
Seeking Ayurvedic Drops for Hearing Improvement
What to do for persistent nose tip pain with bumps and bleeding for several months?
What is causing my throat issues and runny nose during seasonal changes?
Constant Runny Nose and Sneezing
Can I use drops for excessive nasal discharge and sneezing for 2 years?
Seeking Treatment for Vertigo and Left-Sided Pain
Why is my nostril blocked at night?
Why do my ears feel blocked when I sleep and when I grind my teeth?
Chronic Sinusitis Concerns
How to Help My Baby Stop Mouth Breathing After a Cold?
Persistent Sneezing Issues
Ear Blockage and Cold in My 14-Year-Old Son
What is the best Ayurvedic treatment for persistent post-nasal drip after a cold and sinus infection?
What to do for a very dry throat with chronic tonsillitis and no cough or nasal discharge?
How to treat ear blockage caused by cleaning with earbuds?
Experiencing Ear Fullness and Digestive Issues
What to do for ringing in the ears and how to improve my diet?
What to do for stabbing pain in my right ear that won't go away after using drops and heat pack?
What is the best medicine for tinnitus and hearing loss in adults?
Persistent Throat Discomfort and Mucus Sensation
Concerns About My Daughter's Adenoids Treatment and Face Rash
What to do for a blocked nose at night that causes breathing difficulties for 5 months?
Seeking Treatment for My 92-Year-Old Mother's Ear and Balance Issues
How to treat my 11-year-old daughter's persistent throat and nose congestion with green and white mucus?
How to use Anu Thailam for nasal block after a cold?
What to do for voice loss and difficulty speaking after steam inhalation?
How to use sesame oil for sinus and sleep issues every night?
Seeking Ayurvedic Solutions for My Daughter's Adenoid Issues
Recurring Sneezing Issues
How to treat persistent post-nasal drip after a cold and sinus infection for 2.5 months?
Managing Sinus Allergies from Cedar Pollen
What to do for persistent cold sensation in throat and chest pain lasting several days?
Ayurvedic treatment options for chronic sinusitis and tonsil issues in my 27-year-old son
What can I use to treat otosclerosis and Meniere's disease for severe vertigo and spinning?
Ayurvedic Guidance for My Daughter's Hearing Loss After Meningitis
Seeking Ayurvedic Treatment for Ear Issues and Digestive Problems
Regaining My Sense of Smell After a Year
Tonsil Pain with Fever and Eye Discharge
Persistent Throat Tightness and Redness
What to use at home to soften ear wax for my husband who is trying to remove it?
Is the dosage of Nasollerin safe for my 8-year-old with adenoid issues?
What to do for hearing loss and clogged ears when I have a cold and sneezing?
How to treat ringing and blockage in my ears as a mother?
Is it safe to use mustard oil for nasal dryness in summer?
What to do for ear discharge and pain?
Can I take steam inhalation for chronic sinusitis while drinking alcohol daily and taking medication for blood pressure and sugar?
What to do for persistent nose dripping, cough, fatigue, and blurred vision?
What to do if my 13-year-old has a burning throat after taking kayam churna?
What could be causing throat and ear pain in my 68-year-old mom who has been using Ayurvedic medicines for sciatica for the past 3 months?
How long does it take for Sapling tablets to stop nasal discharge, and do I need to take any other medicines with it?
Seeking Permanent Relief from Sinus Issues
Seeking Help for Chronic Nasal Congestion
What to do for my 2-year-old with swollen tonsillitis and 102-degree fever?
What to do for continuous ear ringing and itching after sinus infection and antibiotics?
What is causing my child's persistent hoarseness and how to treat it?
What to do if my daughter feels a clogged ear and pain when swallowing?
What to do for my daughter's painful swelling near her ears and jaw area that keeps coming back?
What to do if my 9-month-old child is pricking their ear but has no pus or fever?
Struggling with Severe Cold and Nasal Blockage After Panchakarma
Inquiry about Powder to Prevent Cold and Sinus Issues After Hair Wash
How to treat swollen left tonsil with throat and ear pain, mucus, and cough?
Can I apply something in my nostril at night for excessive mucus and sinus issues?

Doctors online

Latest reviews

Caleb
11 hours ago
Thanks so much for the detailed and thoughtful answer. Really appreciated the clarity and Ayurvedic insight—I feel much more at ease!
Thanks so much for the detailed and thoughtful answer. Really appreciated the clarity and Ayurvedic insight—I feel much more at ease!
Zoe
1 day ago
Really helpful answer! Thanks for breaking things down so clearly. Feels reassuring to know the options for keeping everything in check.
Really helpful answer! Thanks for breaking things down so clearly. Feels reassuring to know the options for keeping everything in check.
Xanthe
1 day ago
Thanks for the detailed answer—you totally nailed my worries about this condition. It's great to have a plan to work with now!
Thanks for the detailed answer—you totally nailed my worries about this condition. It's great to have a plan to work with now!
Morgan
1 day ago
Really appriciate the detailed answer! The step-by-step guide makes it easy to follow, feel more confident tackling the rash now! Thx!
Really appriciate the detailed answer! The step-by-step guide makes it easy to follow, feel more confident tackling the rash now! Thx!