is makhana good for kidney patients - #24313
I am dealing with some health worries related to my kidneys. A couple of months ago, I found out that my kidney function isn't great. My doctor said I need to be careful about what I eat, especially with high potassium and phosphorus stuff. Lately, I’ve been hearing about makhana and its supposed health benefits, but I’m not sure if is makhana good for kidney patients like me? I mean, I love snacking, but I don't want to mess up my progress. I read online that makhana has various nutrients, and people say it's great for overall health. Still, does it really help or could it be risky for someone with kidney issues? I tried them roasted once, but I didn't love the flavor honestly. Now I'm thinking maybe I could add them to soups or something? 🤔 I want to be careful, but they seem so healthy! Is makhana good for kidney patients? Any advice or personal experiences?? Appreciate it!
100% Anonymous
completely confidential.
No sign-up needed.

Doctors’ responses
Makhana, or fox nuts, hail from the lotus plant and are known in Ayurveda for their potential health benefits. Generally considered nourishing, makhana is light, crunchy, and high in protein, making it a preferred snack option. However, when it comes to kidney health, there’s more to consider. Given your kidney concerns, keeping an eye on your potassium and phosphorus intake is crucial.
For kidney patients, especially those with compromised function, potassium and phosphorus levels need close management. Makhana tends to be relatively low in these minerals compared to other nuts and seeds, so it might be a safer snack compared to, say, almonds or peanuts. Yet, moderation is key here; eating them in large amounts could still pose risks, especially as each person’s condition and tolerance levels can vary widely.
From an Ayurvedic perspective, makhana is said to help strengthen the tissues (dhatus) and support reproductive health. They might also help balance kapha dosha due to their light and drying qualities. This could be beneficial if your current imbalance involves excessive kapha, which may manifest in symptoms like water retention or lethargy, though seek a personalized assessment for confirmation.
Adding them to soups could be a wise choice—by cooking them, you could modify their heavier quality and make them easier to digest, fitting to support your digestive fire (agni). But remember, always cook them well, and don’t overdo it. Regular portion sizes and preparation in soups or light curry could be more agreeable taste-wise if they’re not too enjoyable roasted alone.
Keep also an eye on how you are feeling after eating makhana, and if you notice any changes, consult your nephrologist. Prioritizing regular kidney function checks and discussing any dietary changes with your healthcare provider remains essential to managing your kidney health. If you think any new symptoms arise or there’s change in your condition, please reach medical attention.

100% Anonymous
600+ certified Ayurvedic experts. No sign-up.
About our doctors
Only qualified ayurvedic doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service. You can check the qualification confirmation in the doctor's profile.