Canola oil vs mustard oil: Which is better for overall health?

Question

I’ve been trying to switch to a healthier lifestyle and make more informed choices when it comes to my diet. One thing that’s been on my mind lately is the choice of cooking oil. Growing up, we always used mustard oil at home, but recently I’ve been hearing a lot about canola oil being healthier and better for weight management. So, I’m curious—canola oil vs mustard oil, which is better for overall health?

I’ve heard mixed opinions from my family and friends. My aunt swears by mustard oil, saying it’s great for digestion and good for heart health, while my cousin says that canola oil is more heart-healthy because it has lower saturated fats and more omega-3s. I have a tendency to get confused when so many people say different things!

I also came across some studies saying that mustard oil can be inflammatory if consumed in large amounts, so now I’m worried. I don’t want to end up making a choice that harms my health. I’m particularly concerned because I’ve been dealing with some mild inflammation around my joints recently, and I wonder if the oils I’m using might be contributing to that.

I’ve always believed in traditional methods and prefer natural, unprocessed products in my diet. But given that canola oil vs mustard oil seems to have such differing health effects, I’m not sure what’s best for me. Should I keep using mustard oil, or is it better to switch to canola oil for its lighter texture and benefits for cholesterol levels?

I also want to mention that I’ve been trying to maintain a balanced diet with more fruits, vegetables, and lean proteins, but I still struggle with weight loss and digestion issues sometimes. Would switching to canola oil vs mustard oil help in terms of better digestion or weight management?

Lastly, I’ve been considering consulting an Ayurvedic doctor about my diet and oil choices. Are there any specific oils recommended in Ayurveda for maintaining a healthy heart and digestion? Is mustard oil more suited for certain body types, or would canola oil be a safer bet for someone with a Vata-Pitta constitution like mine?

Dr Sujal Patil · Accepted Answer

Mustard Oil vs Canola Oil: Health Comparison

Mustard Oil:
Pros: High in monounsaturated fats, good for heart health, aids digestion, and has anti-inflammatory properties.
Cons: Contains erucic acid, which in large amounts may cause inflammation (though the levels in food-grade mustard oil are low).
Canola Oil:
Pros: Low in saturated fats, high in omega-3 fatty acids, good for heart health, and supports cholesterol levels.
Cons: Refined varieties may lose some nutrients, and it's often heavily processed.
For Weight Management & Digestion:

Canola oil may be better for weight loss due to its lower saturated fat content.
Mustard oil can help with digestion but might be heavy for some people, especially if you have mild inflammation.
Ayurvedic Perspective (Vata-Pitta)

Mustard Oil: Good for Vata and Kapha types as it’s warming and stimulating. However, Pitta types may find it too heating, especially in large amounts.
Canola Oil: More balanced, lighter, and better suited for Pitta and Vata-Pitta constitutions due to its cooling properties.
Recommendation:

If you’re focusing on heart health and digestion, mustard oil can be great in moderation.
For a lighter, heart-healthy option with less risk of inflammation, canola oil may be the better choice, especially for someone with a Vata-Pitta constitution.
Balance is key: you can use both oils depending on your needs and preferences.

Dr. Ayush Varma · Answer

Well, you’ve got a lot going on with those cooking oils. First, both mustard oil and canola oil each have their own pros, and neither is inherently better—it really depends on your unique constitution and health goals.

Now, you're dealing with a Vata-Pitta constitution and coping with some inflammation around the joints. Mustard oil actually aligns better with Vata dominance due to its warming properties. It boosts digestion (agni) and, when used moderately, can help with healthy circulation and immunity due to its rich presence of omega-3 fatty acids. However, you’re right—excess can sometimes trigger Pitta, causing inflammation, which isn’t what you need.

Canola oil, on the other hand, is often promoted for its heart-friendly reputation, due to the lower saturated fat content and higher omega-3. Considering a blend or alternating with the more neutral canola oil might balance things out for you, reducing that Pitta-related inflammation and still supporting heart health. For digestion and weight, focus more on how you use them – cook on low heat to retain benefits and avoid trans fats.

Vata-Pitta individuals often need a stable routine to calm their doshas. Keep meals warm, freshly cooked, and moderate. Don’t go overboard with refrigeration or microwaving the oils like mustard and canola—loses prana, that life force, ya know?

Aside from oils, try including spices like ginger, turmeric (for anti-inflammatory benefits), and cumin in your dishes—your digestion will thank you. They’re great for stirring up agni, the digestive fire you might be struggling with.

If weight loss is a priority, ensure you’re not over-restricting calories either. Fuel with enough carbohydrates and proteins at regular intervals to sustain metabolism. Keep the fruits and veggies happening, and minimize processed food, sugar and refined grains—u’d be surprised at their sneaky weight-gaining ways.

Ayurveda often praises oils like sesame for Vata folks, but for your constitution, a teeny bit of moderation and balance should work wonders. And yeah, definitely check with an Ayurvedic practitioner for personalized advice—they can assess if there's some hidden imbalance swaying your health decisions.

In the end, mixing the wisdom of tradition with personal needs always tends to get the best results!

Canola oil vs mustard oil: Which is better for overall health? - #10091

Doctors’ responses

About our doctors

Related questions

Popular questions

Doctors online

Latest reviews