Mustard oil vs olive oil: Which is better for health?

Question

I’ve been trying to choose a healthier cooking oil for my family, but I’m confused about which one to pick between mustard oil and olive oil. Both seem to have unique benefits, but I’m not sure which is better for overall health. Mustard oil vs olive oil: Which is better for health, and how do they compare in terms of nutritional value and versatility?

From what I’ve read, mustard oil is commonly used in Indian cooking and is known for its high smoking point, which makes it great for frying. It’s also rich in omega-3 fatty acids and has antibacterial properties. Olive oil, on the other hand, is famous for its heart-healthy monounsaturated fats and is a staple in Mediterranean diets. How do the benefits of these two oils differ? For example, is mustard oil better for cooking Indian dishes, while olive oil is ideal for raw salads or low-heat cooking?

I’ve also heard that mustard oil has a strong flavor, which may not suit everyone, while olive oil is milder and more versatile. Does this mean olive oil is easier to incorporate into a variety of recipes, or can mustard oil be used in innovative ways beyond traditional cooking?

Another concern is health conditions. Is one oil better suited for people with specific issues like high cholesterol or joint pain? For example, does mustard oil’s omega-3 content make it more effective for reducing inflammation, or does olive oil’s antioxidant properties provide more overall health benefits?

If anyone has used both mustard oil and olive oil, I’d love to hear your experience. Which one do you prefer, and why? Do you use them for different purposes, or have you found one to be superior in terms of taste, health benefits, or versatility?

Dr Sujal Patil · Accepted Answer

When choosing between mustard oil and olive oil, both offer unique health benefits, but their suitability depends on the cooking method and specific health goals.

Mustard Oil:
Nutritional Profile: Mustard oil is rich in omega-3 fatty acids, which support heart health and reduce inflammation. It also contains monounsaturated fats and erucic acid, which has antibacterial properties.
Best For: Mustard oil has a high smoking point, making it great for frying and deep-frying in Indian cooking, especially for dishes like curries and stir-fries. It's also a popular ingredient for pickling.
Flavor: Mustard oil has a strong, pungent flavor, which may not appeal to everyone, but it’s beloved in traditional Indian dishes and can be used in innovative ways like in marinades or dressings.
Health Considerations: Mustard oil’s omega-3 content can be beneficial for reducing inflammation, potentially helping with joint pain. However, its high erucic acid content means it should be consumed in moderation.
Olive Oil:
Nutritional Profile: Olive oil, especially extra virgin olive oil, is rich in monounsaturated fats, particularly oleic acid, which is heart-healthy and can help lower LDL cholesterol. It also has a high antioxidant content, particularly vitamin E and polyphenols, which reduce oxidative stress and inflammation.
Best For: Olive oil is ideal for low-heat cooking, drizzling over salads, and raw consumption like in dressings or dipping sauces. Its moderate smoking point (around 375°F or 190°C) makes it less suitable for high-temperature frying.
Flavor: Olive oil has a milder, more subtle flavor, which makes it more versatile for a wide range of dishes, including Mediterranean, European, and even some Asian cuisines.
Health Considerations: Olive oil is known for its anti-inflammatory properties, which may be beneficial for conditions like joint pain and arthritis. Its antioxidants also offer heart protection and may reduce the risk of chronic diseases.
Health Considerations:
Cholesterol & Heart Health: If you're looking to manage cholesterol levels, olive oil is a better choice due to its heart-healthy fats, which can lower LDL (bad) cholesterol and increase HDL (good) cholesterol.
Joint Pain & Inflammation: Both oils have anti-inflammatory properties, but mustard oil’s omega-3s may be more specifically effective for reducing joint pain and inflammation, while olive oil’s antioxidants may offer broader health benefits, especially for heart health.
Versatility in Cooking:
Mustard Oil is primarily used in Indian cooking for deep-frying and sautéing. Its strong flavor can make it harder to incorporate into non-Indian dishes.
Olive Oil is more versatile, especially in Mediterranean diets, and works well in raw dishes, salads, and low-heat cooking. It is widely used for drizzling, sautéing, and even in baking.
Which One to Choose?
Mustard Oil may be the better choice for high-heat cooking, traditional Indian recipes, and those seeking the anti-inflammatory benefits of omega-3s.
Olive Oil is ideal for heart health, raw dishes, and low-heat cooking, offering more versatility for various cuisines and health conditions.
Personal Experience:
Many people use both oils for different purposes. Olive oil is often the go-to for daily use, especially in salads and low-heat cooking. Mustard oil, on the other hand, is more suited for traditional or regional dishes where its flavor is desired.

In summary, both oils have their place in a balanced diet, and incorporating both into different meals can provide a range of health benefits. It ultimately comes down to your specific health needs, flavor preferences, and cooking style.

Dr. Ayush Varma · Answer

Choosing between mustard oil and olive oil can be a bit of a head-scratcher, especially since both have their own unique perks. From an Ayurvedic perspective, both oils can be good for health in different ways, and the right choice often depends on one's individual constitution (prakriti), dosha imbalances, and specific health concerns.

Mustard oil, with its pungent flavor, is rich in omega-3 fatty acids, and has natural antibacterial and antifungal properties. Its heating qualities make it great for individuals with Kapha dosha imbalances, as it can help stimulate agni—your digestive fire. It's particularly good for frying and sautéing because of its high smoking point. If you're cooking Indian dishes, mustard oil can enhance flavors and provide warmth, but its strong taste might sometimes overpower milder ingredients when used outside traditional recipes.

Olive oil, meanwhile, shines with its high content of monounsaturated fats and antioxidants. It's considered excellent for Vata and Pitta types due to its cooler nature. The heart-healthy benefits of olive oil are well-documented, particularly in Mediterranean diets, where it plays a big role in maintaining cardiovascular health. It's usually better for low-heat cooking, salad dressings, and drizzling over dishes for added flavor.

For those with high cholesterol, both oils can be beneficial, but olive oil's ability to raise HDL (good cholesterol) makes it a winner in the heart health category. And for joint pain or inflammation, while mustard oil's omega-3 fatty acids are beneficial, olive oil may offer broader inflammation control due to its antioxidants.

You’re right about the versatility. Olive oil is often easier to integrate into a variety of dishes because of its milder flavor, while mustard oil can be an acquired taste but worth exploring for its unique flavor profile. Try using mustard oil for traditional recipes like Indian pickles or curries where its robust taste can really shine.

Think about your regular meals and family preferences. If you love Mediterranean cuisine or enjoy raw salads, keeping a bottle of good extra virgin olive oil might be the way to go. However, if you’re often frying or making Indian dishes, mustard oil could be ideal. Maybe you'll even find it practical to have both in your pantry for different uses!

Both oils have their distinct advantages—neither outdoes the other definitively. It's all about balancing taste, the dishes you often make, and any specific health goals you have in mind.

Mustard oil vs olive oil: Which is better for health? - #10513

Doctors’ responses

About our doctors

Related questions

Popular questions

Doctors online

Latest reviews