Ask Ayurveda

FREE! Ask Ayurvedic Doctors 24/7

Get expert answers from certified doctors anytime

Fast responses
1000+ verified doctors
/
/
/
is gur better than sugar
Nutrition
Question #36807
211 days ago
501

is gur better than sugar - #36807

Andrew
FREE

I am really confused about something and could need your help. I was at a family gathering the other day, and everyone was arguing about whether is gur better than sugar. My aunt swears that gur is way healthier and has some benefits that sugar doesn't. But then my cousin jumped in and said that it’s just another form of sugar, right? I’ve been feeling sluggish lately, and I’m not sure if my regular sugar intake is part of the problem, like maybe it’s messing with my energy levels or something. I read somewhere that gur can actually give you more sustained energy because it releases more slowly? I mean, I tried switching to gur a couple of weeks ago, and yeah, I noticed I feel less tired during the day, but is that just a placebo effect? Honestly, I don’t know if it’s because of the gur or I just got enough sleep! Plus, I have some cravings for sweet stuff, but when I use gur, I feel like I’m not overdoing it. Is it really true that is gur better than sugar? And is there a right way to use it in my daily routine? Thanks a ton for any tips!

Question is closed
Writing an explanation of your symptoms through Ayurveda...
Analyzing through Ayurvedic framework0%

Doctors' responses

When comparing gur (jaggery) and sugar, there are nuances that make gur a more favorable choice in certain contexts within Ayurveda. Gur is less processed than refined sugar, and retains some beneficial minerals like iron, magnesium, and potassium due to its traditional preparation methods. This makes gur not just a source of calories, but also of micronutrients which can contribute to overall health if consumed mindfully.

In Ayurveda, energy levels and clarity can indeed be influenced by the type of sugar you consume. Gur is said to have a more beneficial effect on energy levels, as it’s less taxing on your body’s metabolic processes, causing a slower release of sugar into the bloodstream compared to refined sugar. This effect may be what you’ve noticed, as traditional refined sugar can contribute to rapid spikes and crashes in blood sugars. Hence, it can be linked to feeling sluggish or experiencing fatigue.

For someone feeling generally low on energy, integrating gur into your diet might provide more sustained energy release. However, it’s important to note that while gur can be a better option, moderation is essential. It is still a form of sugar and excessive intake can have similar impacts to refined sugar such as weight gain or blood sugar issues.

In Ayurveda, balance is the key. You could consider replacing sugar with gur in your tea or any dish where you usually use sugar, while maintaining an overarching balanced diet. When one has sweet cravings, a small piece of gur could be satisfying due to its rich texture and complex taste.

Additionally, it’s wise to pay attention to your overall lifestyle and diet. Ensure you’re getting adequate sleep, staying hydrated, engaging in regular physical activity and consuming a diet rich in whole foods. These factors could also significantly contribute to your energy levels and well-being.

If cravings or energy issues persist, it may be beneficial to explore further dietary adjustments or seek personalized advice from an Ayurvedic practitioner. They can provide tailored recommendations based on your unique dosha balance and lifestyle.

12821 answered questions
29% best answers

0 replies

Gur, or jaggery, does have some advantages over refined sugar, primarily due to the way it’s processed. While sugar often undergoes significant refining, stripping away minerals, jaggery retains more of the natural minerals like iron and magnesium. These minerals can support overall health and may contribute to the sustained energy release you noticed.

In the context of Siddha-Ayurveda, jaggery is deemed to be sattvic, or pure, with potential to balance the vata dosha, which might be beneficial if you’re feeling sluggish and have dry skin issues associated with vata imbalances. The slow release of energy content and nutrients in jaggery after a meal could indeed help maintain stable energy levels, so it’s not purely a placebo effect you’re experiencing.

However, gur does still contain sugar and can affect blood sugar levels, so moderation is key. It’s definitely not a license to overindulge in sweets, but it might help you manage cravings a bit better. If used judiciously, such as adding a small amount to porridges or teas, it can satisfy your sweet tooth without going overboard.

To integrate gur into your diet, try having it post-lunch as a digestive aid, especially if you’re feeling heavy. Chew on a small piece or add it to warm water for a soothing drink. Yet, if energy dips persist, it’s wise to assess other factors in your routine—sleep, hydration, and balanced meals.

Remember, if you’re experiencing consistent fatigue, consult with a healthcare professional to rule out any underlying conditions. Gur can be a more nutritious option than refined sugar, but it’s important to consider total daily sugar intake and overall lifestyle.

13597 answered questions
30% best answers

0 replies

About our doctors

Only qualified ayurvedic doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service. You can check the qualification confirmation in the doctor's profile.


How to use shilajit herb for health benefits and what dosage is recommended?
How to choose between Ashwagandha root powder and extract powder?
How to increase height for a 15-year-old girl who is 139 cm tall?
Seeking a Safe Weight Loss Plan for Abdominal and Thigh Fat
Can I cook bitter gourd with raw mango, and is this combination safe?
How to improve nutrition and protein intake for a 54-year-old with digestion issues and low appetite?
Can I mix papaya seeds and bananas together for health benefits, and what happens if I take them 3 times a week?
How to cleanse my gut and gain weight with food intolerances?
How to use Tulsi seeds for digestive health and parasite cleansing?
How quickly do chia seeds soaked in water leave the stomach and affect nutrient absorption?
What are the benefits of drinking water with cinnamon sticks, hot or cold, and overnight in coffee?
Do Chia Seeds with Lemon Juice Increase Body Heat?
Can I mix oven roasted sunflower seeds with roasted pumpkin seeds and eat them daily?
How to use Shatavari for height increase at 19 years old?
How to help my overweight 15-year-old son control his appetite and boost metabolism?
Can I give moringa powder to my 13-year-old daughter for height growth?
When is the best time to consume chia seeds for managing blood sugar, and how do I use them effectively?
How to gain muscle as a 53-year-old vegetarian bodybuilder?
Can I give honey to my child and how much is safe for children and diabetics?
How to increase my weight when I've been underweight for 2 years despite eating well?
How to gain weight at 19 years old with a height of 165cm and weight of 47kg?
Plant-Based Diet for Muscle Gain and Energy
Is golden milk with turmeric and ghee good for a 17-year-old pitta dosha boy at night?
How to use Alfa Alfa tonic for weight gain during periods?
Best Anti-Inflammatory Oils and Teas for Pitta Dosha
Is drinking diluted white vinegar with green tea, lemon, and hot water good for my health?
How to help my 21-month-old child gain weight and reduce frequent potty after eating?
How to reduce belly fat with Ayurveda for someone with a sedentary IT job?
What are the best supplements for a breastfeeding mother to maintain wellness, and can I take Krishna’s Thyrocare Juice or Patanjali Thyrogrit while breastfeeding?
How to quickly increase my 2.5-year-old child's hemoglobin level from 10?
Can I drink yogurt lassi after eating jackfruit?
How to increase appetite and gain weight after delivery when nothing seems to help?
What Ayurvedic medicines like leghyams can help me gain weight in a month?
How to gain weight with a strong appetite and Vata Pitta prakriti?
When should a diabetic person consume panner phool, before or after meals?
How to increase my 15-year-old daughter's weight with Ayurvedic foods or herbs?
Diet Suggestions for Weight Gain Without Wheat, Dairy, and Sugar
Is it healthy to cook chicken with yogurt or should I use tomatoes instead?
How to use Varanasi Kadayam for weight loss and how long should I take it?
What is the difference between turbinado sugar and white sugar, and how does sharkara sugar compare?
What are some cooling foods like chia seeds for a TCM heat damp clearing detox diet?
Do Chia Seeds Help with Weight Loss?
How to gain weight at 30 years old with low body fat and visible bones?
Seeking Authentic Chyawanprash for Skin, Hair, and Well-being
Can I eat murabba with papaya for breakfast to aid digestion?
Can I drink watermelon juice after curd without losing its benefits?
What to do for bloating, low appetite, and weak stomach muscles with a weight of 48 kg?
Is it safe to eat curd with seeds and oats in the morning?
How long before dinner should I take Ayurvedic weight supplement and is it harmful?
Nutritional Deficiencies and Mood Issues
How to lose weight after menopause for a 53-year-old woman on a vegan diet?
What to feed my 4-year-old daughter to help her become mentally and physically strong after meningitis and seizures?
Can I take supplements for weight gain while breastfeeding my 1.5-year-old baby?
How to combine foods according to Ayurvedic principles for better health?
How to use Shatavari for height increase in a 19-year-old girl?
How to help my 18-month-old daughter gain weight when she's eating well but not gaining?
How to eat muli (radish) with yogurt for best health benefits?
What are the benefits of fennel seeds and how to make fennel water for weight loss?
How to use Kali Mirch, Baheda, and Magpipal powder for weight loss — should I take it after meals or on an empty stomach?
How to gain weight and muscle at 35 years old, and when should I eat fruits for better results?
How to use medicine for weight loss while going to the gym for a 5'7" female weighing 82 kg?
How to lose weight with PCOD on a budget for a married woman?
How to lose weight quickly without a diet plan?
How to increase my height at 23 years old with a good diet?
How to help my 13-year-old son lose body fat and promote height growth safely?
What are some meals I can eat for fat loss at 18 years old and 64 kg?
Seeking Help to Increase Weight at Age 50
What is the best time to eat fresh fruit and how long should I wait before having dairy?
How to lose weight with an Ayurvedic diet if I eat a lot due to anxiety?
What diet should I follow after fasting to stay healthy and gain weight?
Is it safe to mix different types of millets for sprouting and making powder?
How much Moringa powder should a 17-year-old take for height increase and can it be taken with other medications for fungal infection?
How to use navel oiling for fast weight loss and brighter skin at 17?
How to create an Ayurvedic meal plan for Kapha-Pitta with high Vata after Panchakarma treatment?
How to gain weight safely without side effects and improve skin health?
Is it safe to add curd to dal rice paste for fermentation to make dhokla?
How to make and use moringa leaf powder, and what are its benefits and side effects?
How to Balance My Dosha Naturally?
What happens if I don't rinse barley before cooking with lemon juice and honey?
How to use Satavari for weight gain during breastfeeding and how long can I take it?
Is a peanut and decaf coffee blend with oat milk a good protein drink for older Vata types in warm South India?
What foods should I eat or avoid with a Pitta constitution and abdominal pain after spicy foods?
What foods can help boost metabolism and reduce belly fat naturally?
How to use Shilajit herb for health benefits and what is the recommended dosage?
Is it safe to heat curd when making idli or appam with suji?
What is the best Pitta dosha diet plan and what foods should I avoid?
How to convert 40cc of AMLA juice to the equivalent amount of AMLA powder?
Can I eat dosa, idli, and upma in moderation if I have high diabetes and high cholesterol?
How to lose weight fast for a 17-year-old girl using Ayurvedic options?
How to use Ashwagandha in baking recipes for bread and cookies?
How to lose weight after pregnancy when I can't exercise and my weight is 93kg?
How to feed my autistic child with fatty liver who refuses to exercise and has lost weight from 110 to 96 kilos?
What can I eat for high cholesterol and fatty liver at 48 years old?
How to create Asian meals for a firmer belly after menopause at 69?
Can I reduce Drakshadi Kashaya dosage from 4 tsp to 2 tsp without losing effectiveness?
Is it safe to eat soaked chia seeds and drink cucumber juice every day?
How long can I safely take fenugreek water and soaked seeds for digestion and blood sugar regulation?
How to increase appetite and gain weight for a 36-year-old with low appetite?
Is it recommended to have almond milk for breakfast every day if I'm a Pitta-Vata with Vata imbalance?
Struggling with Nutritional Absorption and Gut Health

Doctors online

Latest reviews

Lucy
12 hours ago
Thanks for the great advice! Super clear and simple. I'll definitely give those exercises a try. Appreciate the help!
Thanks for the great advice! Super clear and simple. I'll definitely give those exercises a try. Appreciate the help!
Christopher
16 hours ago
This answer was spot on! It's great you took the time to thoroughly explain everything. Feel so much clearer, thank you!
This answer was spot on! It's great you took the time to thoroughly explain everything. Feel so much clearer, thank you!
Mya
16 hours ago
Thanks so much for the detailed response! Your insights on pulling back on certain treatments make a lot of sense. Feeling hopeful! 😊
Thanks so much for the detailed response! Your insights on pulling back on certain treatments make a lot of sense. Feeling hopeful! 😊
Bella
16 hours ago
Really appreciated the clear advice in the response! Made so much sense and I feel hopeful now about managing my symptoms better. Thanks a ton!
Really appreciated the clear advice in the response! Made so much sense and I feel hopeful now about managing my symptoms better. Thanks a ton!