क्या BAMS और MD इन सर्जरी वाले बड़े ऑपरेशन कर सकते हैं?

Question

क्या BAMS और MD इन सर्जरी वाले डॉक्टर, MBBS और MD सीनियर डॉक्टर के अंडर पूरी तरह से प्रैक्टिस करके बड़ी सर्जरी कर सकते हैं या नहीं?

Dr. M.Sushma · Accepted Answer

in india a bams doctor even with md ayurveda surgery is not legally permitted to independently perform major allopathic surgeries

however the situation is clarified as follows

a bams doctor with md ayurveda shalya tantra can assist observe and gain practical exposure in surgeries only under supervision of a qualified mbbs ms or md allopathic surgeon

they cannot independently operate perform major surgeries sign consent or be the primary surgeon in allopathic surgical procedures

even if they have trained for years under senior mbbs or md surgeons the law does not allow independent practice of major allopathic surgery

what they can legally do
perform ayurvedic surgical procedures described under ayurveda
assist in surgeries in hospitals as a surgical assistant where permitted
manage pre and post operative care under supervision
work in ayurvedic hospitals where surgical procedures are ayurvedic in nature

what they cannot legally do
perform major allopathic surgeries independently
represent themselves as allopathic surgeons
open a surgical practice for allopathic procedures

some states previously allowed limited practice but court rulings and medical council regulations have restricted this strongly

so the final answer is
no a bams md surgery doctor cannot legally do major allopathic surgeries independently even after long practical exposure under mbbs md surgeons

Dr. Ravi Chandra Rushi · Answer

According to NCISM (National Commission for Indian System of Medicine) –
Scope of surgeries for MS (Shalya Tantra)
MS (Shalya Tantra) post-graduates are legally permitted to perform surgical and para-surgical procedures as per NCISM / Indian Medicine regulations, within their training and institutional setup.
Permitted procedures
1. Anorectal surgeries
Ksharasutra for Bhagandara (fistula-in-ano)
Fistulotomy / Fistulectomy
Arsha (Hemorrhoids):
Kshara karma
Agnikarma
Hemorrhoidectomy
Parikartika (Fissure-in-ano):
Lord’s dilatation
Internal sphincterotomy
Pilonidal sinus surgery
2. General surgical procedures
Incision & drainage of abscess
Excision of lipoma, sebaceous cyst, ganglion
Wound suturing and debridement
Sinus excision
Corn and wart excision
3. Para-surgical procedures
Kshara karma (chemical cauterization)
Agnikarma (thermal cauterization)
Jalaukavacharana (leech therapy)
Siravyadha (venesection)
4. Selected major surgeries (as trained during MS Shalya & permitted by institution/state rules)
Hydrocele
Hernia (uncomplicated cases)
Varicose veins (selected cases)
Important NCISM points
Practice must be within Shalya Tantra syllabus & training
Surgeries allowed independently in Ayurvedic hospitals
In mixed/allopathic hospitals → depends on state government & hospital bylaws
Use of modern anesthesia, investigations & instruments is permitted

Dr RC BAMS MS (Gen surgery)

Dr. Ramkabir Mayankkumar Rushibhai · Answer

केवल BAMS से आप बड़ी सर्जरी नहीं कर सकते, लेकिन BAMS पूरा करने के बाद AIPGT परीक्षा देकर और MS शल्य तंत्र, प्रसूति तंत्र, शालक्य तंत्र की शाखा में दाखिला लेकर कुछ प्रकार की सर्जरी स्वतंत्र रूप से कर सकते हैं। BHU, ITRA, NIA जैसे बेहतरीन संस्थान सर्जरी के लिए सबसे अच्छे विकल्प हैं।

Dr. Prasad Pentakota · Answer

THANKS FOR CONTACTING US IN ASK AYURVEDA
AS PER INDIAN MEDICAL CONCIL BAMS DOCTORS WITH MS DEGREE CAN`T PERFORM MAJOR SURGERIES. THEY CAN ASSIST ALLOPATHIC SURGEON DURING SURGERY. 
INDEPENDENTLY YOU CANT OPERATE CARDIAC SURGERIES
WITH WARM REGARDS 
DR.P.PRASAD

क्या BAMS और MD इन सर्जरी वाले बड़े ऑपरेशन कर सकते हैं? - #47616

इस स्थिति के लिए डॉक्टर द्वारा सुझाए गए उपचार

डॉक्टरों की प्रतिक्रियाएं

ऑनलाइन डॉक्टर

हमारे डॉक्टरों के बारे में

ऑनलाइन डॉक्टर

नवीनतम समीक्षाएँ