Ask Ayurveda

FREE! Ask an Ayurvedic Doctor — 24/7
Connect with Ayurvedic doctors 24/7. Ask anything, get expert help today.
Orthopedic Disorders
Question #17941
158 days ago
194

Femur - #17941

Emma

A few months ago, I had an accident and fractured my femur. At the time, I was rushed to the hospital, where they took X-rays and put my leg in a cast. The doctor prescribed calcium and vitamin D supplements to help with healing, but I’ve noticed that my leg still feels weak, and I occasionally experience pain, especially when I try to put too much weight on it. The healing process has been slow, and I’m worried about my bone strength in the long run. Doctor, I want to know if Ayurveda can help in strengthening the femur bone and speeding up the healing process. Are there Ayurvedic herbs or treatments that promote bone regeneration and reduce post-fracture pain? I’ve read that Hadjod, Ashwagandha, and Shatavari are beneficial for bones—how should they be taken, and do they actually help in faster recovery? I also want to ensure that my bones remain strong and don’t become weak over time. Are there Ayurvedic dietary recommendations that can improve bone density and prevent future fractures? I’ve read that excessive vata imbalance in Ayurveda can lead to brittle bones. Should I be taking any herbal tonics or making specific lifestyle changes to strengthen my skeletal system? Doctor, can you suggest an Ayurvedic treatment plan that includes dietary changes, herbal remedies, and any therapies that will help in complete recovery from a femur fracture and overall bone health?

FREE
Question is closed
FREE! Ask an Ayurvedic Doctor — 24/7,
100% Anonymous
Get expert answers anytime,
completely confidential.
No sign-up needed.
CTA image

Doctors’ responses

Ayurveda offers a holistic approach to healing fractures by promoting Asthi Dhatu (bone tissue) regeneration and balancing Vata dosha, which governs bone health. Since a femur fracture is a major injury, a combination of herbal supplements, dietary support, and external therapies can help speed up recovery, reduce pain, and strengthen bones. The slow healing process could be due to poor calcium absorption, weak digestion, or an aggravated Vata dosha, which needs to be addressed for long-term bone health.

Ayurvedic herbs like Hadjod (Cissus quadrangularis), Ashwagandha, and Shatavari are excellent for bone healing. Hadjod is known for its fracture-healing properties and can be taken as a powder or tablet with warm milk. Ashwagandha strengthens bones and muscles, while Shatavari supports overall bone density. You can also include Guduchi (Tinospora cordifolia) and Laksha (Laccifer lacca) to enhance calcium absorption and bone regeneration. Muktashukti Bhasma (a natural calcium supplement) and Praval Pishti are Ayurvedic mineral preparations that support bone healing when taken under an expert’s guidance.

A Vata-pacifying diet is crucial for bone strength. Include calcium-rich foods like sesame seeds, almonds, dates, leafy greens, dairy (if tolerated), and figs. Warm, nourishing foods like soups, ghee, and bone broths are beneficial. Avoid excessive caffeine, processed foods, and dry or cold foods, which can aggravate Vata and slow healing. External therapies like Dashmool oil or Mahanarayana oil massages can improve circulation and relieve post-fracture stiffness.

For long-term bone health, consider Panchakarma therapies like Basti (medicated enema) to balance Vata and strengthen the skeletal system. Practicing gentle yoga and physiotherapy exercises will help restore mobility without straining the bone. By following a structured Ayurvedic treatment plan with herbal support, a balanced diet, and external therapies, you can accelerate femur healing and maintain strong bones in the future.

11913 answered questions
78% best answers
Accepted response

0 replies
Dr. Harsha Joy
Dr. Harsha Joy is a renowned Ayurvedic practitioner with a wealth of expertise in lifestyle consultation, skin and hair care, gynecology, and infertility treatments. With years of experience, she is dedicated to helping individuals achieve optimal health through a balanced approach rooted in Ayurveda's time-tested principles. Dr. Harsha has a unique ability to connect with her patients, offering personalized care plans that cater to individual needs, whether addressing hormonal imbalances, fertility concerns, or chronic skin and hair conditions. In addition to her clinical practice, Dr. Harsha is a core content creator in the field of Ayurveda, contributing extensively to educational platforms and medical literature. She is passionate about making Ayurvedic wisdom accessible to a broader audience, combining ancient knowledge with modern advancements to empower her clients on their wellness journeys. Her areas of interest include promoting women's health, managing lifestyle disorders, and addressing the root causes of skin and hair issues through natural, non-invasive therapies. Dr. Harsha’s holistic approach focuses on not just treating symptoms but addressing the underlying causes of imbalances, ensuring sustainable and long-lasting results. Her warm and empathetic nature, coupled with her deep expertise, has made her a sought-after consultant for those looking for natural, effective solutions to improve their quality of life. Whether you're seeking to enhance fertility, rejuvenate your skin and hair, or improve overall well-being, Dr. Harsha Joy offers a compassionate and knowledgeable pathway to achieving your health goals.
157 days ago
4.83

In Ayurveda, bone health is closely linked to the balance of Vata dosha, which governs movement and structure in the body, and the nourishment of Rakta (blood) and Asthi dhatu (bone tissue). A slow healing process after a bone fracture, especially the femur, may indicate a Vata imbalance, which can result in brittle or weak bones. Ayurveda offers a holistic approach to accelerate healing, reduce pain, and improve long-term bone health through a combination of herbal remedies, dietary changes, and lifestyle modifications.

To promote bone regeneration, Ayurveda recommends Hadjod (also known as Cissus quadrangularis), which is known to support bone healing and reduce pain. It can be taken as a powder or in capsule form, often in combination with other herbs like Ashwagandha (to reduce inflammation and improve muscle strength) and Shatavari (to strengthen the tissues and rejuvenate the body). Ashwagandha helps to balance Vata and Pitta doshas, which can accelerate recovery, while Shatavari helps in tissue healing and promotes strength. These herbs can be taken daily in the form of powders, tablets, or decoctions, under the guidance of an Ayurvedic practitioner.

For long-term bone health, Ayurveda emphasizes a nutritious diet rich in foods that nourish the Asthi dhatu. Include calcium-rich foods like sesame seeds, leafy greens, almonds, and milk. Bone broth (prepared with herbs like turmeric, ginger, and black pepper) is also beneficial for strengthening bones and improving joint health. Consuming ghee and healthy fats like olive oil supports the absorption of nutrients and nourishes the tissues.

Ayurveda also suggests avoiding foods that deplete Vata, such as excessively cold or dry foods, and focusing on warm, easily digestible meals. Include spices like turmeric, ginger, and garlic in your diet to reduce inflammation and support healing.

Panchakarma therapies (detoxification treatments) can also be useful for balancing Vata and promoting tissue regeneration. External treatments like Abhyanga (oil massage with warm sesame oil) can help improve circulation and support the healing process by relaxing the muscles and bones.

Yoga and gentle exercise are important once the fracture begins to heal. Poses that focus on strengthening the legs, such as Warrior Pose and Mountain Pose, can help promote bone density. However, these should only be done under professional supervision and after the fracture has healed sufficiently to avoid further injury.

Overall, a combination of Ayurvedic herbs, dietary changes, lifestyle practices, and regular exercise will not only support faster healing but also ensure that your bones stay strong and resilient in the long term.

13739 answered questions
68% best answers

0 replies

I’m glad you’re seeking a comprehensive approach to heal and strengthen your bones post-fracture. Based on your circumstances and the Ayurvedic principles, here’s a personalized treatment plan tailored to your needs.

Dietary Recommendations: 1. Include Bone-Building Foods: - Milk and Dairy: Consume warm milk daily, optionally with a pinch of turmeric and a few almonds. - Leafy Greens: Incorporate spinach, kale, and fenugreek, which are high in calcium. - Seeds: Include sesame seeds (til) and flaxseeds for their omega-3s and calcium. - Legumes: Consume lentils and chickpeas for protein and nutrients.

2. Ayurvedic Dietary Practices: - Cook with oils like ghee (clarified butter) and sesame oil, which help nourish the bones. - Avoid excessive cold or raw foods, as they can aggravate vata, leading to brittleness.

Herbal Remedies: 1. Hadjod (Cissus quadrangularis): - Take 1-2 teaspoons of Hadjod powder mixed with warm water or honey twice daily. This herb is known for promoting bone healing and regeneration.

2. Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera): - Use 1 teaspoon of Ashwagandha powder, preferably in warm milk or water, once daily. It supports overall vitality and stress reduction, which can aid in healing.

3. Shatavari (Asparagus racemosus): - Consume Shatavari in powder form or capsules, following the package instructions, as it helps in strengthening tissues and is beneficial for hormonal balance.

Lifestyle Adjustments: 1. Gentle Exercise: - Engage in gradual weight-bearing activities like walking, under supervision. Start with short durations, increasing as discomfort permits.

2. Massage: - Regularly apply warm sesame or mustard oil to the leg, which helps improve circulation and nourish the bones.

3. Routine: - Maintain a consistent sleep schedule and engage in mindfulness practices such as meditation to reduce stress, aiding in overall recovery.

Long-Term Bone Health: - To prevent future fractures, consider periodic Ayurvedic assessments to monitor dosha balance. Following a balanced diet rich in calcium and engaging in weight-bearing exercises will further solidify your bones’ strength.

Follow-Up: Make sure to consult your healthcare provider regularly about your pain and progress. If pain worsens or your condition does not improve steadily, seek their advice urgently.

This holistic approach combining diet, herbs, and lifestyle adjustments should set you on a path toward not only recovery but also lasting bone health.

1742 answered questions
27% best answers

0 replies
Speech bubble
FREE! Ask an Ayurvedic doctor — 24/7,
100% Anonymous

600+ certified Ayurvedic experts. No sign-up.

About our doctors

Only qualified ayurvedic doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service. You can check the qualification confirmation in the doctor's profile.


Related questions

Doctors online

Dr. Maitri Bhavesh Kumar Acharya
ChatGPT said: I am Dr. Maitri, currently in my 2nd year of MD in Dravyaguna, and yeah, I run my own Ayurvedic clinic in Ranoli where I’ve been seeing patients for 2 years now. Honestly, what pulled me into this path deeper is how powerful herbs really are—when used right. Not just randomly mixing churnas but actually understanding their rasa, virya, vipaka etc. That’s kinda my zone, where textbook knowledge meets day-to-day case handling. My practice revolves around helping people with PCOD, acne, dandruff, back pain, stiffness in knees or joints that never seem to go away. And I don’t jump to giving a long list of medicines straight away—first I spend time figuring out their prakriti, their habits, food cycle, what triggers what… basically all the small stuff that gets missed. Then comes the plan—herbs (single or compound), some diet reshuffling, and always some lifestyle nudges. Sometimes they’re tiny, like sleep timing. Sometimes big like proper seasonal detox. Being into Dravyaguna helps me get into the depth of herbs more confidently. I don’t just look at the symptom—I think okay what guna will counter this? Should the drug be snigdha, ushna, tikta? Is there a reverse vipaka that’ll hurt the agni? I ask these questions before writing any combo. That’s made a huge diff in outcomes. Like I had this case of chronic urticaria that would flare up every week, and just tweaking the herbs based on sheetala vs ushna nature... helped calm the system in 3 weeks flat. Not magic, just logic. I also work with women who are struggling with hormonal swings, mood, delayed periods or even unexplained breakouts. When hormones go haywire, the skin shows, digestion slows, and mind gets foggy too. I keep my approach full-circle—cleansing, balancing, rejuvenating. No quick fixes, I tell them early on. What I’m hoping to do more of now is make Ayurveda feel practical. Not overwhelming. Just simple tools—ahara, vihara, aushadha—used consistently, with some trust in the body’s own healing. I’m still learning, still refining, but honestly, seeing people feel in control of their health again—that’s what keeps me rooted to this.
5
168 reviews
Dr. Hemanshu Mehta
I am Dr. Hemanshu—right now a 2nd year MD scholar in Shalya Tantra, which basically means I’m training deep into the surgical side of Ayurveda. Not just cutting and stitching, btw, but the whole spectrum of para-surgical tools like Agnikarma, Viddhakarma, and Kshara Karma... these aren’t just traditional, they’re super precise when done right. I’m not saying I know everything yet (still learning every day honestly), but I do have solid exposure in handling chronic pain issues, muscle-joint disorders, and anorectal conditions like piles, fissures, fistulas—especially where modern treatments fall short or the patient’s tired of going through loops. During clinical rounds, I’ve seen how even simple Kshara application or well-timed Agnikarma can ease stuff like tennis elbow or planter fasciatis, fast. But more than the technique, I feel the key is figuring what matches the patient’s constitution n lifestyle... like one-size-never-fits-all here. I try to go beyond the complaint—looking into their ahar, sleep, stress levels, digestion, and just how they feel in general. That part gets missed often. I honestly believe healing isn’t just a “procedure done” kind of thing. I try not to rush—spend time on pre-procedure prep, post-care advice, what diet might help the tissue rebuild faster, whether they’re mentally up for it too. And no, I don’t ignore pathology reports either—modern diagnostic tools help me stay grounded while applying ancient methods. It’s not this vs that, it’s both, when needed. My aim, tbh, is to become the kind of Ayurvedic surgeon who doesn't just do the work but understands why that karma or technique is needed at that point in time. Every case teaches me something new, and that curiosity keeps me moving.
5
111 reviews
Dr. Anirudh Deshmukh
I am Dr Anurag Sharma, done with BAMS and also PGDHCM from IMS BHU, which honestly shaped a lot of how I approach things now in clinic. Working as a physician and also as an anorectal surgeon, I’ve got around 2 to 3 years of solid experience—tho like, every day still teaches me something new. I mainly focus on anorectal care (like piles, fissure, fistula stuff), plus I work with chronic pain cases too. Pain management is something I feel really invested in—seeing someone walk in barely managing and then leave with actual relief, that hits different. I’m not really the fancy talk type, but I try to keep my patients super informed, not just hand out meds n move on. Each case needs a bit of thinking—some need Ksharasutra or minor para surgical stuff, while others are just lifestyle tweaks and herbal meds. I like mixing the Ayurved principles with modern insights when I can, coz both sides got value really. It’s like—knowing when to go gentle and when to be precise. Right now I’m working hard on getting even better with surgical skills, but also want to help people get to me before surgery's the only option. Had few complicated cases where patience n consistency paid off—no shortcuts but yeah, worth it. The whole point for me is to actually listen first, like proper listen. People talk about symptoms but also say what they feel—and that helps in understanding more than any lab report sometimes. I just want to stay grounded in my work, and keep growing while doing what I can to make someone's pain bit less every day.
0 reviews
Dr. Ayush Varma
Graduating with an MD in Ayurvedic Medicine from the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) in 2008, he brings over 15 years of expertise in integrative healthcare. Specializing in complex chronic conditions, including autoimmune disorders, metabolic syndromes, and digestive health, he uses a patient-centered approach that focuses on root causes. Certified in Panchakarma Therapy and Rasayana (rejuvenation), he is known for combining traditional Ayurvedic practices with modern diagnostics. Actively involved in research, he has contributed to studies on Ayurveda’s role in managing diabetes, stress, and immunity. A sought-after speaker at wellness conferences, he practices at a reputable Ayurvedic wellness center, dedicated to advancing Ayurveda’s role in holistic health and preventive care.
4.95
20 reviews
Dr. Deepali Goswami
I am Dr. Deepali Goswami, BAMS graduate n working mainly around women's health. Right now m running my own clinic where i treat all kind of gyne problems—from irregular periods to PCOD, white discharge, fertility-related issues, menopausal symptoms n lot more that affects everyday life of females. I usually try to keep the language simple while dealing with patients cause honestly half of them come already confused or like really scared of what's happening inside their body... and if I use too much technical terms it just make it worse. I’ve been practicing in this space for couple of years now—don’t remember the exact month, maybe two or three year back? but anyway, what matters is I’ve seen how many of these problems get ignored till they turn serious. That’s something I feel strongly about. My goal is to help women understand their symptoms early and explain how Ayurveda can help gently but properly, whether it’s hormonal stuff or pain or cycle issues. I use classic Ayurvedic concepts like dosha analysis, ritucharya, n yoni vyapad chikitsa wherever it fits, but sometimes modern lifestyle really needs to be factored in too. Like if someone working night shift, no point telling them to wake up at 5am and do abhyanga daily—it won’t work. I’m practical about it. Anyway, I try my best to create a space where women feel heard. Lot of them said nobody actually explained them what’s going on before. And that’s like the saddest part. I feel my biggest strength is really just listening n tailoring the treatment to her routine, diet n stress pattern. Some cases are harder of course... things don’t always go fast, esp when it’s been neglected for yrs. But then Ayurveda’s not magic. It takes a little time—but results feel real n lasting when done right.
5
6 reviews
Dr. Arun Desai
I am Dr. Arun Desai, working in Ayurveda for 19+ years now, both online and offline. My clinic, Ayur Sanjivani, is at #44 B 1, Opp Adarsh Laundry, beside Tej Residency, near Kavalemath Somwaar Peth Cross in Tilakwadi, Belgaum – bit of a long address but patients seem to find it just fine. Over time I’ve learned that people today want relief fast but still safe and lasting. That’s where I mix the depth of classical Ayurveda with practical tweaks to suit this fast moving lifestyle. I don’t like giving something that just masks a symptom – I want to get to the root cause whenever possible. At the clinic, I try to keep things warm and easy to talk, not a stiff doctor’s table vibe. Whether it’s diagnosis, a Panchakarma session, or simple counseling, I want patients to feel they can ask anything, even small doubts. Education matters too – when someone understands why a certain diet or lifestyle change is needed, they actually follow it better. Treatments may include herbal formulations, diet charts, yoga routines, exercise plans, detox, anti-stress work – all depending on their prakruti and condition. Over the years, I’ve treated people from many walks of life – each case different, which keeps me learning. Some come for joint pain, some for skin problems, others for lifestyle disorders like diabetes or high BP. I still follow authentic Ayurvedic principles but adapt them so they work in today’s reality. And yes, I’m always updating my knowledge, making sure the practice stays ethical and effective, because for me, Ayurveda isn’t just treatment – it’s a way to help someone rebuild their health from inside out.
5
70 reviews
Dr. Khushboo
I am someone who kinda started out in both worlds—Ayurveda and allopathy—and that mix really shaped how I see health today. My clinical journey began with 6 months of hands-on allopathic exposure at District Hospital Sitapur. Honestly, that place was intense. Fast-paced, high patient flow, constant cases of chronic and acute illnesses coming through. That taught me a lot about how to see disease. Not just treat it, but like… notice the patterns, get better at real-time diagnosis, really listen to what the patient isn’t saying out loud sometimes. It gave me this sharper sense of clinical grounding which I think still stays with me. Then I moved more deeply into Ayurveda and spent another 6 months diving into clinical training focused on Panchakarma therapies. Stuff like Abhyanga, Basti, Shirodhara—learned those not just as a list of techniques, but how and when to use 'em, especially for detox and deep healing. Every case felt like a different puzzle. There wasn’t always one right answer, you know? And that’s where I found I loved adapting protocols based on what the person actually needed, not just what the textbook says. Alongside that, I got certified in Garbha Sanskar through structured training. That really pulled me closer to maternal health. Pregnancy support through Ayurveda isn’t just about herbs or massage, it’s like this entire way of guiding a mother-to-be toward nourishing the baby right from conception—emotionally, physically, all of it. That part stuck with me hard. My overall approach? It’s kinda fluid. I believe in balancing natural therapies and evidence-based thinking. Whether it's seasonal imbalance, hormonal issues, Panchakarma detox plans, or just guiding someone on long-term wellness—I like making people feel safe, heard, and actually understood. I’m not into rushing plans or masking symptoms. I’d rather work together with someone to build something sustainable that really suits their body and where they’re at. In a way, I’m still learning every day. But my focus stays the same—use Ayurvedic wisdom practically, compassionately, and in a way that just... makes sense in real life.
5
51 reviews
Dr. Anjali Sehrawat
I am Dr. Anjali Sehrawat, a graduate of National College of Ayurveda and Hospital, Barwala, Hisar, where I completed my BAMS in 2023. My professional journey reflects a balanced integration of both Ayurvedic and Allopathic systems of medicine, allowing me to adopt a versatile and patient-centric approach to healthcare. During my academic and clinical training, I gained hands-on experience in diagnosing and managing a wide range of health conditions by combining the principles of Ayurveda with evidence-based modern medicine when required. This dual perspective has enhanced my ability to deliver more comprehensive and customized treatment plans suited to the individual needs of each patient. Currently, I am undergoing residency training, where I continue to deepen my clinical skills and refine my expertise under the guidance of senior practitioners. I am passionate about holistic healing, preventive healthcare, and lifestyle management, with a strong commitment to treating the root cause of illnesses rather than merely addressing the symptoms. My goal is to ensure that every patient receives safe, ethical, and effective treatment rooted in the rich tradition of Ayurveda, complemented by modern insights where appropriate.
5
1 reviews
Dr. Keerthana PV
I am a passionate and responsible Ayurvedic doctor, having completed my internship at the renowned VPSV Ayurveda College, Kottakkal, Kerala. My clinical journey has been shaped by the rich traditions of Kerala Ayurveda, where I gained extensive hands-on experience in diagnosing and treating patients with authentic Ayurvedic therapies. I am dedicated to delivering personalized and holistic healthcare, with a focus on preventive medicine and positive lifestyle modification. I actively counsel my patients on achieving optimal health through balanced diet, daily regimen, stress management, and natural therapies. Additionally, I am a certified Smrithi Meditation Consultant from the Kottakkal Ayurveda School of Excellence, which allows me to integrate meditation and mindfulness techniques into my treatment protocols, promoting mental well-being along with physical health. My approach is rooted in compassion, responsibility, and a commitment to empowering patients on their journey towards complete wellness.
5
95 reviews
Dr. Narendrakumar V Mishra
I have been practicing as a Consulting Ayurvedic Physician since 1990, with over three decades of clinical experience in treating a wide range of chronic and lifestyle-related health conditions. My core areas of focus include hair disorders, skin diseases, and lifestyle disorders such as diabetes, arthritis, and stress-related imbalances. Over the years, I have developed a patient-centric approach that emphasizes deep-rooted healing through authentic Ayurvedic principles. My treatment philosophy is based on understanding the unique constitution (prakriti) and imbalance (vikriti) of each patient, allowing me to craft individualized care plans using classical formulations, diet corrections, detox therapies (shodhana), and lifestyle modifications. Whether it’s persistent hair fall, recurring skin allergies, or long-term metabolic disorders, I aim to address the root cause rather than just suppress symptoms. In the management of lifestyle disorders like diabetes and arthritis, I integrate Ayurvedic medicines with structured dinacharya (daily routines) and ahar (dietary guidance), focusing on sustainable results and long-term wellness. I also work extensively with stress-related concerns, offering holistic strategies that incorporate mind-body practices, including meditation, herbal support, and counseling rooted in Ayurveda. With a strong foundation in traditional Ayurvedic texts and decades of hands-on experience, I remain committed to providing safe, natural, and effective healthcare solutions. My goal is to guide patients toward a balanced life, free from chronic ailments, through personalized treatment protocols that restore harmony to both body and mind.
5
354 reviews
Dr. Karthika
I am currently a PG second-year student in the Shalakya Tantra department at Parul Institute of Ayurveda and Research (2024 batch). I completed my UG and immediately joined PG in a regular batch. I secured the university second rank in Pondicherry University (CCRAS syllabus) at Rajiv Gandhi Ayurveda Medical College (2017 batch). With exposure to both modern and Ayurvedic knowledge of all eye diseases, I am also skilled in cornea and cataract surgeries. During my deputation in the second year of PG, I was trained to handle 200+ patients in 1-2 hours. I secured a distinction in my first-year PG with 82%, achieving department first and university first at Parul Institute of Ayurveda and Research, Vadodara, Gujarat.
5
125 reviews

Latest reviews

Abigail
14 hours ago
Thanks for the clear advice! Your response really helped me understand what my mom might be going through. Appreciate it!
Thanks for the clear advice! Your response really helped me understand what my mom might be going through. Appreciate it!
Savannah
16 hours ago
Thanks for your great advice! Your response really helped me understand more clearly if my symptoms are serious or not. Appreciate it!
Thanks for your great advice! Your response really helped me understand more clearly if my symptoms are serious or not. Appreciate it!
Thomas
16 hours ago
I found the answer really helpful! Got straight to the point and gave me peace of mind. Appreciate the clear guidance. Thanks a bunch!
I found the answer really helpful! Got straight to the point and gave me peace of mind. Appreciate the clear guidance. Thanks a bunch!
Nora
16 hours ago
Thanks for the clear advice doc! Appreciate how you broke it down and asked key questions. Feels reassuring to have some direction here!
Thanks for the clear advice doc! Appreciate how you broke it down and asked key questions. Feels reassuring to have some direction here!