Is Taking Milk And Curd Together Harmful

Question

I’ve always been a fan of dairy products and include them a lot in my meals. Sometimes I’ll have milk in the morning, and later in the day, I’ll eat curd with lunch or dinner. Recently, someone told me it’s not good to have milk and curd close to each other. Now I’m wondering, is taking milk and curd together harmful? Could this be causing some of the digestion issues I’ve been experiencing, like bloating and occasional stomach discomfort?

I’ve read that Ayurveda talks about food combinations, but I’m not sure how strict it is about this one. Does combining milk and curd create toxins in the body, or is it fine as long as they’re taken at different times? For example if I drink milk in the morning and have curd at lunch, would that still be harmful, or is the issue only when they’re consumed in the same meal?

Another thing I’m curious about is whether this depends on the person’s body type or dosha. I think I might have a kapha-pitta imbalance because I feel heavy after meals and often get heartburn. Could having milk and curd together worsen these symptoms? Does Ayurveda suggest avoiding this combination altogether for people with certain dosha types?

I’ve also noticed that when I eat dishes like raita, which combine curd with spices or other foods, I don’t feel any discomfort. But if I drink a glass of milk after such meals, I sometimes feel a little sluggish. Does this mean the problem isn’t just with milk and curd but with how they interact with other foods in the meal? Or is it more about timing?

Lastly, if taking milk and curd together is harmful, what’s the science or reasoning behind it? Is it just a traditional guideline, or is there evidence that it affects digestion or overall health? I’d love to know if there are specific rules for eating dairy products in Ayurveda to avoid these problems.

Dr. Harsha Joy · Accepted Answer

In Ayurveda, combining milk and curd together is generally considered problematic, especially when consumed in the same meal, due to their opposing qualities. Milk is considered a cooling, nourishing food, while curd (especially if it’s sour) is seen as more acidic and heavier. When these two are combined, it can disrupt digestion by creating an imbalance in the digestive fire (Agni), potentially leading to the formation of toxins (ama) and causing digestive issues like bloating, heaviness, and discomfort. The timing of consumption does matter; having milk in the morning and curd later in the day can be less problematic than consuming them together, as it allows the body to process them separately. Ayurveda also takes dosha imbalances into account—kapha and pitta types may be more sensitive to this combination. For kapha-pitta imbalances, milk and curd together can exacerbate feelings of heaviness, sluggishness, or heartburn. When curd is combined with spices (like in raita), it can aid digestion and balance the dish, making it easier to digest. It’s not just the timing but also how dairy is combined with other ingredients that can affect digestion. The reasoning behind avoiding this combination is rooted in Ayurveda’s principles of balancing opposing qualities in food, which, when mixed improperly, can impair digestion and lead to discomfort or the creation of toxins. For optimal digestion, it’s best to keep dairy products separate or have them with foods that support their qualities.

Dr. Ayush Varma · Answer

Mixing milk and curd can be a bit tricky, indeed. According to Ayurveda, food combination matters ('Viruddha Ahara'), and dairy products like milk and curd actually don't go too well together because of their differing properties. Milk is considered sweet and mildly cooling, while curd is sour and heating. This creates a kind of internal conflict that might disturb digestion, possibly manifesting symptoms like bloating or stomach discomfort which you're experiencing.

If you've identified some kind of Kapha-Pitta imbalance—feeling heavy, experiencing heartburn—then it would make sense to be cautious about consuming these together. Individuals with such imbalances are particularly sensitive to foods that are heavy and could increase internal 'ama' or toxins. Having them at different times seems like a good approach; enjoy milk in the morning and curd separately at lunch. Time helps in reducing the potential adverse effects, but do keep some gap.

Sure, dish like raita often combine curd with spices that aid digestion, maybe that’s why you feel okay digesting it. Spices like cumin, coriander, and pepper can help stimulate your digestive fire or 'agni'. On the other hand, when it comes to drinking milk right after, it might lead to sluggishness because these foods together are a lot for digestion to handle.

Also, timing and the context are crucial. Eating curd later in the day might help increase your energy levels because that's when your digestive fire is naturally stronger. Milk is usually better digested earlier on, perhaps at breakfast.

The science behind this? While it's not stuff modern science focuses on essentially, it works for Ayurvedans. But the body's individual constitution ('dosha') says a lot. So rules might vary from person to person a bit. If you're keenly interested, consult a local Ayurveda practitioner who can provide more personalized guide based on your constitution and history. That being said, balancing your diet with lighter, well-cooked, and spiced foods will usually ease the load, no matter your dosha type.

Is Taking Milk And Curd Together Harmful - #4245

Doctors’ responses

About our doctors

Related questions

Popular questions

Doctors online

Latest reviews