FREE! Ask an Ayurvedic Doctor — 24/7
Connect with Ayurvedic doctors 24/7. Ask anything, get expert help today.
General Medicine
Question #17130
151 days ago
227

BMI Chart - #17130

Ava

I recently started focusing on my health and fitness, and while I’m making improvements, I’m still unsure about what my ideal weight should be. I came across a BMI chart, which is often used to assess whether someone is underweight, normal weight, overweight, or obese based on their height and weight. While I know that BMI is a helpful tool for monitoring general health, I’m wondering how accurate it really is, especially since it doesn’t account for factors like muscle mass or body composition. I’ve been using the BMI chart to track my progress, but I’m not sure if I should be aiming for the “normal” range or if there’s more to health than just a number on the chart. I’m also curious about whether there are other health metrics I should be considering alongside BMI, such as waist-to-hip ratio or body fat percentage, to get a clearer picture of my overall health. Since I’m interested in holistic health and Ayurveda, I’m wondering if Ayurveda offers a different perspective on weight management and healthy body composition. I’ve heard that Ayurveda looks at the body as a whole and emphasizes balancing the doshas, so I’m curious if this approach could help me understand my body better and find a weight range that’s healthy for me. Has anyone used the BMI chart to monitor their health? Did you find it helpful, or did you rely on other metrics? Did Ayurveda offer any insights into healthy weight management?

FREE
Question is closed
FREE! Ask an Ayurvedic Doctor — 24/7,
100% Anonymous
Get expert answers anytime,
completely confidential.
No sign-up needed.
CTA image

Doctors’ responses

It's great that you're focusing on your health and fitness, and it's perfectly natural to feel uncertain about what your ideal weight should be. You're absolutely right that BMI can be a helpful general guideline, but it does have limitations. It primarily assesses weight relative to height and doesn't take into account factors such as muscle mass, body fat percentage, and overall body composition. For example, athletes with higher muscle mass may have a higher BMI, but they could still be in excellent health. That's why considering additional metrics, like waist-to-hip ratio, body fat percentage, and waist circumference, can offer a more comprehensive view of your health. In Ayurveda, the concept of optimal health goes beyond just a number on a scale or chart. It focuses on achieving balance in your physical, mental, and emotional health by addressing the unique constitution or Prakriti of your body, which is made up of your doshas (Vata, Pitta, and Kapha). Each person has a unique balance of these doshas, which influences how they carry weight, metabolize food, and maintain overall health. For example, a person with a Kapha constitution might naturally have a more robust physique, and their ideal weight may be higher compared to someone with a Vata constitution, who tends to be leaner. Ayurveda emphasizes that health is about finding your personal balance, rather than trying to fit into a standard range. Ayurveda also emphasizes the role of digestion and metabolism (Agni) in achieving and maintaining a healthy weight. Rather than focusing solely on calories or numbers, Ayurvedic principles advocate for mindful eating, balancing food with your dosha type, and supporting digestion through herbs, spices, and lifestyle practices. For example, if you're dealing with sluggish digestion or weight retention, Ayurveda might recommend Triphala or Guggulu to enhance metabolism and detoxification. Likewise, if you're more stressed (which can increase cortisol and lead to weight gain), herbs like Ashwagandha and practices like yoga and meditation can help bring balance and reduce stress, which is essential for healthy weight management. Overall, Ayurveda offers a holistic approach that looks at the whole person, rather than just focusing on external measurements. It's about understanding your unique body and how to nurture it back to balance through diet, lifestyle, and mind-body practices. Instead of focusing solely on hitting a target BMI, Ayurveda encourages you to embrace your natural body type and work toward a weight range that supports your physical, mental, and emotional well-being. Working with an Ayurvedic practitioner can help you tailor this approach to your specific needs and find the most sustainable and balanced path toward health.
11913 answered questions
78% best answers
Accepted response

0 replies
Dr. Harsha Joy
Dr. Harsha Joy is a renowned Ayurvedic practitioner with a wealth of expertise in lifestyle consultation, skin and hair care, gynecology, and infertility treatments. With years of experience, she is dedicated to helping individuals achieve optimal health through a balanced approach rooted in Ayurveda's time-tested principles. Dr. Harsha has a unique ability to connect with her patients, offering personalized care plans that cater to individual needs, whether addressing hormonal imbalances, fertility concerns, or chronic skin and hair conditions. In addition to her clinical practice, Dr. Harsha is a core content creator in the field of Ayurveda, contributing extensively to educational platforms and medical literature. She is passionate about making Ayurvedic wisdom accessible to a broader audience, combining ancient knowledge with modern advancements to empower her clients on their wellness journeys. Her areas of interest include promoting women's health, managing lifestyle disorders, and addressing the root causes of skin and hair issues through natural, non-invasive therapies. Dr. Harsha’s holistic approach focuses on not just treating symptoms but addressing the underlying causes of imbalances, ensuring sustainable and long-lasting results. Her warm and empathetic nature, coupled with her deep expertise, has made her a sought-after consultant for those looking for natural, effective solutions to improve their quality of life. Whether you're seeking to enhance fertility, rejuvenate your skin and hair, or improve overall well-being, Dr. Harsha Joy offers a compassionate and knowledgeable pathway to achieving your health goals.
146 days ago
4.83
It's great that you're focusing on improving your health and fitness! While the BMI chart is widely used to assess general health, it's true that it has limitations, especially when it comes to body composition. For example, BMI doesn't distinguish between muscle mass and fat, so someone with a lot of muscle may have a high BMI but still be in excellent health. Additionally, it doesn’t account for factors like distribution of fat or visceral fat, which are important for assessing overall health risks. So, while it can be a useful starting point, it's not the only metric to consider. In addition to BMI, other measurements like waist-to-hip ratio or body fat percentage can offer more insights into your health. A waist-to-hip ratio greater than 0.85 for women or 0.90 for men is associated with a higher risk of health conditions, even if BMI is in the normal range. Body fat percentage is also an important metric, as it helps assess how much fat you have in comparison to lean tissue. From an Ayurvedic perspective, weight management is more individualized. Ayurveda focuses on balancing your doshas (Vata, Pitta, and Kapha) to achieve overall harmony in the body. For example, people with a Kapha imbalance might struggle with weight gain, so Ayurveda suggests lifestyle practices like regular physical activity and a lighter, detoxifying diet. In contrast, individuals with a Vata imbalance may have difficulty maintaining weight and might be encouraged to adopt grounding foods and routines that nourish and stabilize. Rather than focusing solely on a specific weight range, Ayurveda would encourage you to find a weight and lifestyle that feels balanced and supports your overall health—mind, body, and spirit. If you're interested in this approach, working with an Ayurvedic practitioner could help you better understand your dosha and what dietary and lifestyle adjustments might be best for your body type and goals.
13739 answered questions
68% best answers

0 replies
BMI charts are really a mixed bag—they can be useful for getting a quick snapshot of health but they might miss a lot, like you mentioned. You're spot on pointing out BMI doesn't account for muscle mass or body composition. Which can lead to some strange results, like calling a muscular person “overweight”! So yeah, while you can keep an eye on BMI for a general idea, it's definitely not the whole picture. In terms of Ayurveda, things get really interesting. Ayurveda, unlike BMI, sees you as a unique being—so it doesn't clump folk into categories like 'normal' or 'overweight' based solely on height and weight. It focuses more on how your body's functioning in balance with your doshas (Vata, Pitta, Kapha), how strong or sluggish your Agni (digestive fire) is, and the condition of your dhatus (tissues). For instance, a Kapha-dominant person might naturally be a bit heavier and that's perfectly okay in Ayurveda, as long as all else is balanced. It's about finding harmony with your Prakriti, or natural constitution. You could, for instance, focus on eating foods that balance your specific dosha, incorporating spices like ginger or turmeric to enhance digestion, or engaging in activities that keep you rejuvenated. Beyond BMI, consider looking into things like your waist-to-hip ratio—it’s pretty telling about fat distribution, which gives you an idea about risk of certain conditions. Body fat percentage is also good for understanding composition. Yet, Ayurveda leans into practicality—how you feel day-to-day, how’s your energy, sleep, digestive patterns. All revealing in ways numbers aren't. Maybe try also incorporating some daily routines like Abhyanga (self-massage with sesame or coconut oil), meditation, or yoga tailored to your body type. Tracking all these can give you a holistic view. Remember, health isn't one-number-fits-all, especially when we take a holistic view. If unsure about where you need to tweak things, it might be a good idea to speak to an Ayurvedic practitioner who can offer guidance tailored to your constitution. Always makes sense to get a personalized take when it comes to health management!
26394 answered questions
18% best answers

0 replies
Speech bubble
FREE! Ask an Ayurvedic doctor — 24/7,
100% Anonymous

600+ certified Ayurvedic experts. No sign-up.

About our doctors

Only qualified ayurvedic doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service. You can check the qualification confirmation in the doctor's profile.


Related questions