Does acl and meniscus be cured without surgery - #32462
Na to mujhe lagi na kuch hua bas achanak pero mesweeling aa gyi thik na hone pe mri carvayi to usme acl or meniscus aaya then after rest and physio therapy again mrikarvayibutproblem kam ni huyi blki bad gyi what to do next please help age only 25 h surgery nhi kravana chahti hu


Doctors’ responses
Please consult your nearest Panchkarma center.
PANCHAKARMA is your best option here. Go for janu basti with murivenn taila. Upnaha savedana You will find good results.
HELLO SAKSHI,
-ACL (anterior cruciate ligament) is a strong band inside your knee that keeps it stable. When it is torn, the knee may feel loose, unstable, painful and may swell -Meniscus is like a soft cushion (cartilage) between thigh bone and leg bone. It absorbs shock and protects the joint. A tear causes locking, swelling, pain while sitting down or clin=mbing stairs -these structures have poor blood supply-> that’s why natural healing is slow -your MRI showed problems in both ACL + meniscus-> explains why swelling and pain are not going away
TREATMENT GOALS -reduce swelling and inflammation -ccontrol pain and stiffness -strengthen muscles and ligaments to support the knee -prevent further damage and arthritis -balance vata (pain/instability) + kapha (swelling/stiffness) -support thyroid health, since metabolism affects tissue repair
INTERNAL MEDICATIONS
1) MAHAYOGARAJ GUGGULU= 2 tabs twice daily with warm water =reduces pain, inflammation, strengthens bones and ligaments
2) SHALLAKI EXTRACT= 400mg twice daily after meals =natural anti inflammatory improves joint mobility
3) ASHWAGANDHA + SHATAVARI POWDER= 3gm each with warm milk at night =builds strength, reduces vata, nourishes tissues
4) DASHMOOLA KASHAYA= 25ml + equal water twice daily before meals =anti inflammatory, reduce sswelling
5) FOR THYROID= KANCHANAR GUGGULU= 2 tabs twice daily after meals =balances metabolism, prevents weight gain that stresses joints
DURATION= at least 3-6 months
EXTERNAL THERAPIES
1) OIL MASSAGE= daily gentle knee massage with Dhanwantaram taila followed by hot fomentation =increases circulation, reduces stiffness
2) JANU BASTI (clinical procedure)= warm medicated oil pooled on the knee joint for 30 mins daily for 7-14 days =nourishes ligaments and cartilage
3) PATRA PINDA SWEDA (leaf bolus fomentation)= improves strength, reduces swelling
4) LEECH THERAPY= if swelling is severe, leeches remove inflammatory toxins
These therapies are done in cycles of 14-21 days, repeated 2-3 times in a year.
YOGA ASANAS -Tadasana= improves posture -Setubandhasana= strengthens thighs and hips -Supta padangusthasana= improves flexibility -Shalabhasana= strengthen back and hamstring
PRANAYAM -Anulom vilom= balances vata and stress -Bhramari= calms nervous systemm, helps in healing -Kapalbhati= only if thyroid is sluggish
DIET -warm, soft, nourishing foods -khichdi, dal, upma -ghee 1-2 tsp/day -milk,almonds, sesame seeds, drumstick leaves -ginger, turmeric, ajwain= natural anti-inflammatory -seasonal fruits- papaya, pomegranate, berries
AVOID -cold,refrigerated , dry food -excess sour, fermented -pickle, curd at night -excessive wheat based heavy foods -non veg deep fried, red meat
LIFESTYLE -avoid sitting cross-legged or squatting -use western toilet instead of Indian toilet -do not climb stairs repeatedly -use knee brace while walking -maintain normal weight- important in thyroid
HOME REMEDIES -turmeric milk at night -methi soaked seeds= 1 tsp chew in morning -castor oil massage= warm oil massage twice weekly for vata balance -ajwain hot compress= dry roast ajwain, put in cloth pouch use as warm compress for knee swelling
-At 25 years, your priority is to protect the knee long term -If the tear is partial Ayurvedic + physiotherapy treatment can help manage without surgery -If it’s a complete tear with instability, Ayurveda can relieve symptoms but cannot reattach a torn ligament-> in that case, surgery may be required to prevent early arthritis -Best approach= 3-6 months of Ayurvedic + conservative management, regular follow ups
DO FOLLOW
HOPE THIS MIGHT BE HELPFUL
THANK YOU
DR. MAITRI ACHARYA
For ACL and meniscus injury with swelling start Maharasnadi kashayam 15-0-15 ml with water Yograja guggulu-1-0-1 Peedantaka vati 1-0-1 Murivenna oil warm oil to be massaged gently over knees The above treatment can reduce pain, swelling and improve knee stability. In many cases. It will help in postponing the surgery and improves daily movement, but follow up with your orthopaedic. Is important to monitor the joint condition.
Apni latest MRI report ek sports injury/orthopedic surgeon ko dikhaiye.
Pura tear hai ya partial? Meniscus repairable hai ya remove karna padega? Ye sab decide hoga.
Agar partial hai to intensive physiotherapy try kar sakte ho.
Agar complete hai aur symptoms zyada hain, to surgery avoid karna long-term ghutne ke liye risk ban sakta hai.
Ayurveda cannot help you in replacing surgery but to most extent it can help you in reducing pain swelling and inflammation, n sometimes it may postpone the requirement of surgery Yograj guggulu-one tablet, eat twice daily after food with warm water Mahanarayana taila - gentle massage to be done at knees
Start with Yograj guggul 1-0-1 after food with water Ashwagandha tablet 0-0-1 at bedtime with warm milk Shallaki tablet 1-0-1 after food with water Massage with dhanvantrum oil on affected area twice daily Avoid sour fermented foods.
For an ACL or meniscus injury, particularly when surgery is not an option, Ayurveda may offer supportive measures to help alleviate symptoms and strengthen the knee joint. While Ayurvedic treatments can’t entirely replace surgical intervention in severe ligament tears, they can be a useful complement to conventional care, especially for mild to moderate cases.
Start with external therapies such as Abhyanga (oil massage) using Mahanarayan oil or Dhanvantaram oil. These oils have been traditionally used to reduce inflammation and improve joint mobility. Gently massage the affected knee daily to encourage proper circulation and relieve stiffness.
You might explore herbal remedies like Shallaki (Boswellia), Guggulu, or Ashwagandha. These herbs have anti-inflammatory properties and can support the healing process. Traditionally, a dose of 250 mg to 500 mg of Shallaki extract thrice daily may be beneficial, but it’s important to personalize based on individual needs and consult a practitioner before starting any regimen.
Diet plays a crucial role. Incorporate foods that pacify Vata dosha, as Vata is often aggravated in joint issues. Warm, cooked, and easily digestible foods like soups, stews, and khichdi can nourish the tissues. Add spices like ginger and turmeric to your meals for their anti-inflammatory benefits.
Include mild, non-strenuous exercises like yoga or specific physiotherapy-designed movements that maintain joint movement without overexerting. These exercises help in strengthening the muscles around the knee and improving flexibility.
Maintain a regular daily routine to balance Vata. Ensure adequate rest and manage stress levels, as stress can exacerbate Vata imbalances, potentially worsening the condition.
If pain, swelling, or mobility does not improve, re-evaluation by a healthcare professional is advisable. Ayurveda can help improve comfort and support overall joint health, but for serious tears, surgical opinion shouldn’t be dismissed prematurely. It is critical to monitor the situation closely with adequate medical supervision.
1) lakshadi gugglu - 1 tab after food 2 times with ghee and honey
2) tab kokilaksha kashaya - after food 2 times with vidaryadi ghrita 10 ml
3) Ashwagandharishta - 20 ml after food 2 times with water
4) ksheera bala taila 101 + gandha taila 10-10 drop each - before food 2 times with warm milk
While it’s important to follow your physician’s advice, there are certain Siddha-Ayurvedic approaches you might explore for managing ACL and meniscus issues without surgery. Yet, remember, these approaches are supportive and may not replace necessary medical intervention.
Ayurveda views such injuries as primarily linked to Vata dosha imbalance—Vata being responsible for movement and space within the body. First, maintain Vata balance through diet. Include warm, nourishing foods like soups, stews, and kitchari. Avoid cold foods, excessive caffeine or stimulants. Cook with spices like ginger and turmeric, known for their anti-inflammatory properties.
External applications may help—formulations like oils of Ashwagandha or Bala can be massaged gently onto the affected area. Do this twice daily, preferably in the morning and evening. Also, consider herbal preparations such as Shallaki guggulu, which may alleviate knee joint discomfort. Always discuss with a qualified practitioner before starting herbs.
For strengthening, follow gentle yoga and pranayama that focus on knee health. Practices like Makarasana (Crocodile pose) can help, but do them cautiously without straining.
Ensure proper rest, adequate sleep, and reduce any activities that put excessive strain on the knee. Lastly, if pain or immobility increases, it’s important to consult a healthcare provider urgently, as delayed treatment might worsen the condition. This approach should support healing, but keep safety and professional medical guidance as your priority.

100% Anonymous
600+ certified Ayurvedic experts. No sign-up.
About our doctors
Only qualified ayurvedic doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service. You can check the qualification confirmation in the doctor's profile.