Ask Ayurveda

/
/
/
jaggery or sugar which is good for health
FREE! Just write your question
— get answers from Best Ayurvedic doctors
No chat. No calls. Just write your question and receive expert replies
1000+ doctors ONLINE
#1 Ayurveda Platform
Ask question for free
00H : 15M : 47S
background image
Click Here
background image
Nutrition
Question #38503
110 days ago
358

jaggery or sugar which is good for health - #38503

Claire

I am just really confused about something I read lately about jaggery or sugar which is good for health. Like, I've been trying to eat a bit healthier, you know? I always thought sugar was just bad for you, but then I heard people say jaggery is super healthy and better than sugar. Last week, I even tried switching to jaggery in my tea and stuff, but I'm not sure if it's really making any difference. My friends keep saying jaggery has, like, all these minerals and stuff that sugar doesn't, but then I wonder if it’s just the same kind of calories in the end? I mean, I still crave sweets sometimes and I just don't know what to choose. Sometimes I feel so lost – is there really a big difference when it comes to jaggery or sugar which is good for health? I have heard jaggery maybe helps with digestion too, is that true? I feel like I need to understand both of them better because I don’t want to make things worse for my health. Any advice or personal experience would be super helpful!

FREE
Question is closed

Doctor-recommended remedies for this condition

FREE! Ask an Ayurvedic Doctor — 24/7, 100% Anonymous
Get expert answers anytime, completely confidential. No sign-up needed.
background-image
background-image
background image
banner-image
banner-image

Doctors' responses

Choosing between jaggery and sugar can indeed be quite confusing, especially when you’re aiming for healthier choices. Both jaggery and sugar originate from sugarcane, but their processing methods and nutritional content differ. In Ayurveda, jaggery is often favoured over refined sugar for its less processed nature and additional benefits.

Jaggery retains trace amounts of minerals like iron, magnesium, and potassium, which are stripped away during refining sugar. This makes it marginally more nutritious than white sugar. However, it’s important remember that, both, jaggery and sugar, are caloric sweeteners. Consuming them in excess could lead to similar metabolic impacts, such as weight gain or increased blood sugar levels.

In Ayurvedic practice, jaggery is classified as ‘sweet’ but also known to be slightly warming, which can help in balancing Vata dosha and perhaps Pitta, depending on individual constitution. It is also cited for aiding digestion, potentially because of its molasses content, which helps to activate digestive enzymes. If you’re finding digestive discomfort, incorporating small quantities of jaggery with meals might offer some relief. Pay attention whether it feels beneficial to your digestive fire, or agni, after meals.

Yet, the final choice between jaggery and sugar should hinge on personal tolerance and mindful consumption. If you experience any form of imbalance such as increased Pitta (excess heat), it would advisable to monitor jaggery intake. Try staying aware of your body’s responses and balancing your overall diet with sufficient hydration, fibers, and movement. Moderation remains key, as high intake of either sweetener might adversely impact your health goals. Instead of replacing sugar with large amounts of jaggery, consider reducing total sweetener use wherever possible.

When choosing jaggery, ensure it is a quality, unadulterated product. Combining it with ginger or fennel in warm water can be an excellent digestion-friendly tonic. But if you ever feel overwhelmed concerning your dietary choices, consulting with an Ayurvedic practitioner for tailored advice might be highly beneficial.

11499 answered questions
28% best answers

0 replies

In the context of a healthier lifestyle, the choice between jaggery and sugar can indeed seem perplexing. Both serve as sweeteners but have different effects on health, according to the principles of Siddha-Ayurveda.

From an Ayurvedic perspective, jaggery is often considered a more wholesome alternative to refined sugar. It retains trace minerals like iron, magnesium, and potassium, which are stripped away during the refining process of white sugar. These minerals can support several bodily functions, making jaggery slightly more nourishing. For individuals with pitta dosha imbalance, which might manifest as inflammation or acidity, jaggery’s sweet and slightly astringent taste can balance this dosha when consumed in moderation. However, jaggery is still a source of sugar and can lead to increased kapha if overeaten, potentially causing lethargy or weight gain.

In terms of digestion, jaggery is believed to help activate the digestive fire, or agni, enhancing appetite and aiding in the assimilation of nutrients. It can be especially beneficial during cooler months when vata dosha is predominant. Opting for jaggery in such times might promote warmth and aid digestion.

Yet, the core calories and sugar content don’t differ remarkably between jaggery and refined sugar. Therefore, the intake level should be kept moderate to prevent blood sugar spikes, given the sugar content in both. Switching to jaggery doesn’t eliminate calories; hence, mindful consumption is key.

To incorporate jaggery effectively, replace sugar in teas, desserts, and as a post-meal item, preferably consumed shortly after midday for optimal digestion according to the circadian rhythm of body’s digestive capacity.

For long-lasting energy and balanced diet, pairing it with foods rich in healthy fats and proteins, like nuts or dairy, can prevent rapid chances in blood sugar levels. If you have any underlying conditions like diabetes, it would be best to consult with a healthcare provider before making any significant dietary changes.

11935 answered questions
28% best answers

0 replies
Speech bubble
FREE! Ask an Ayurvedic doctor — 24/7,
100% Anonymous

600+ certified Ayurvedic experts. No sign-up.

About our doctors

Only qualified ayurvedic doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service. You can check the qualification confirmation in the doctor's profile.


Related questions

Doctors online

Latest reviews

Luke
21 minutes ago
Thanks a ton for the thorough breakdown! Your response made things clearer and was just what I needed. Really appreciated!
Thanks a ton for the thorough breakdown! Your response made things clearer and was just what I needed. Really appreciated!
Lincoln
3 hours ago
Thanks for confirming the meds are safe. Relieved to know your answer was clear n simple, very reassuring!
Thanks for confirming the meds are safe. Relieved to know your answer was clear n simple, very reassuring!
Olivia
3 hours ago
Really helpful response! Appreciate the clear guidance on managing BP with Mukta Vati and lifestyle tips. Feeling more at ease now. Thanks!
Really helpful response! Appreciate the clear guidance on managing BP with Mukta Vati and lifestyle tips. Feeling more at ease now. Thanks!
Landon
3 hours ago
Thanks for clearing that up! I was kinda worried about combining them. Guess I should chill on the drinks if I want max benefits! 🙏
Thanks for clearing that up! I was kinda worried about combining them. Guess I should chill on the drinks if I want max benefits! 🙏