Joint Knocking Sounds – Is This Normal for Vata? Ayurvedic Remedies & Advice - #31319

Hello, 1. Yes. It is normal to have a knocking sound in the joints for a vata person, if it is not associated with stiffness&/pain and swelling in the joints. 2. As mentioned above if no stiffness, pain and swelling there is no need to get concerned. Having said that, as you are VATA you need to take care of your joints. 3. a. Continue having ghee. b. Start applying Sesame oil to the joints/if there is an availability start applying to whole body 30 minutes before hot to warm water shower, the KSHEERABALA THAILAM/SHUDHA BALA THAILAM every day. c. Start drinking water boiled with cumin seeds(one liter a day) d. Avoid raw food and curds after 0600PM. e. Once a year for 45 days take capsule ksheerabala 101 drops 2 capsules in the morning and 2 capsules in the evening one hour before breakfast and dinner.

Take care, Kind regards.

NO NEED TO WORRY DEAR,

First of all avoid excessive vatavardhak ahar vihar like too spicy, bitter, astringent food, capsicum, pea,brinjal, cauliflower etc.

Daily Massage your full body with KSHEERBALA TAILAM followed by mild fomentation with DASHMOOL KASHAYAM.

JANU BASTI WITH KSHEERBALA TAILAM ×15DAYS.

Start taking these medications, 1.Maharasnadi kwath 20ml with equal amount of Lukewarm water empty stomach twice in a day. 2.Tab. Rumalya forte 1-1-1 3.Mahayograj guggulu 2-0-2 for chewing 4.Giloy ghan vati 1-1-1

Follow up after 15 days.

Take care😊

Kind Regards, Dr.Isha Ashok Bhardwaj

HELLO AKSHAY,

You are 34, Vata Prakriti, lean build, and physically active. Crackling/ popping sounds in joints, especially on movement, suggest Vata moving in the joints

WHAT’S HAPPENING? -Vata has quality of dryness, lightness, mobility. In joints this can reduce natural lubrication. When joints are “drier” than they should be , the bones/ligaments may rub slightly, creating sound

IS IT HARMFUL? -If there’s no pain, swelling, stiffness or weakness, it’s not disease- more a sign of early vata aggravation. If neglected, over Years it could move toward sandhigata vata (osteoarthritic tendencies)

TREATMENT GOALS -pacify vata= restores lubrication, warmth, and stability -nourish joints and tissues= keep bones strong, prevent degeneration -improve digestion and metabolism= ensure nutrients reach joints -maintain flexibility without strain= balance between activity and rest -prevent progression= catch imbalance early, stop it from becoming disease

INTERNAL MEDICATIONS

1) ASHWAGANDHA CHURNA= 1 tsp with warm milk at night =strengthens bones, muscles, and calms vata

2) YOGARAJ GUGGULU= 2 tabs twice daily after meals =classic for vata in joints, prevents stiffness, improves mobility

3) DASHMOOLA KASAHYA= 40 ml twice daily before meals with warm water =reduces vata in joints, relieves inflammation if any

4) GANDHARVAHASTADI TAILA (mild purgative) -DOSE= 1 tsp at bedtime occasionally once a week with warm milk =clears excess vata from colon, root of all vata disorders

EXTERNAL THERAPIES

1) OIL MASSAGE= Mahanarayan taila -warm oil massage daily before bath 10-15 minutes self massage on joints =restores lubrication, strengthens joints, calms vata

2) If assessable gentle steam on joints after oiling =softens stiffness, allows oil to penetrate

DIET -warm, moist foods- soups, khichdi, stews -ghee daly 2-4 tsp/day -nuts/seed= sesame, soaked almonds, walnuts -milk with turmeric and ghee at night -root vegetables, moong dal, urad dal , rice, wheat

spices= ginger, garlic, turmeric, cumin

AVOID -excess dry foods-crackers, raw salads -too much millet very trying, balance with rice/wheat -cold drinks, refrigerated food

YOGA ASANAS -pawanmuktasana series - joint rotations -vajrasana, malasana- gentle squates -bhujangasana, shalabhasana - strengthens spine/hips -avoid jerky or high impact movements

PRANAYAM -nadi sodhana= balances vata -bhramari= calms nervous system -avoid excessive kapalbhati

HOME REMEDIES -warm sesame oil massage -A glass of warm turmeric milk with ghee at night -Fenugreek seeds soaked overnight, chewed in morning -Herbal teas= dry ginger + ajwain + cumin post meals if digestion feels heavy

Right now, Akshay your joints are just “talking” a bit- more like a reminder than an alarm. Ayurveda sees this as early vata dryness, not a disease yet. By adding oiliness (inside+outside), warmth, and stability to your routine, you can keep your joints healthy for decades

THE MOST IMPORTANT PILLARS FOR YOU -Daily oil massage -nourishing warm diet with ghee, milk, sesame, nuts -regular, gentle exercise + yoga -Internal oiliness

This way, you’re not just treating the sound- you’re strengthening the whole system, preventing vata from becoming troublesome later

THANK YOU

HOPE THIS MIGHT BE HELPFUL

DR. MAITRI ACHARYA

Hello. At 34 age this is not much normal . As u said ur Vataj Prakruti avoid having too much millets and big size pulses. This increased more vata. Do whole body massage with Seasame oil /Bala oíl followed by hot water bath as frquently. Take5 ml Panchatikta grit 1/2 hr before meals with warm water for 1 month. Tab Asthiposhak 1 tab 2 times a day

Ayurvedic principles suggest that cracking or popping sounds in joints, especially in a person with a Vata constitution, can be a sign of Vata imbalance. This is because Vata governs movement and is associated with the elements of air and ether. An excess of Vata can lead to dryness in the body, which can affect the lubrication (known as sleshaka kapha) of the joints, causing them to make these sounds.

​Here is a breakdown of your questions and some Ayurvedic guidance:

​Is this normal, especially for someone with a Vata constitution? ​While common for Vata types, it is not considered ideal. The sounds suggest a lack of proper lubrication in the joints. Vata individuals are naturally prone to dryness, so if their lifestyle, diet, or environment is aggravating Vata, this dryness can manifest as cracking joints, dry skin, and constipation. Your current routine and diet seem to be mostly supportive, but certain subtle imbalances could be at play.

​Should I be concerned, or is there something I should do to address this? ​It’s not a cause for immediate alarm, especially if there is no pain, but it is a signal from your body that needs attention. Addressing this now can help prevent potential long-term issues, such as joint degeneration or arthritis, which are often linked to chronic Vata imbalance in Ayurveda.

​Ayurvedic Remedies, Supplements, and Dietary Changes ​The goal is to pacify Vata by increasing warmth, moisture, and nourishment.

​Dietary Adjustments: ​Increase Healthy Fats: You are already consuming ghee, which is excellent. Consider increasing the amount slightly, perhaps to 3-4 teaspoons a day, especially during colder or drier weather. Ghee is considered a rasayana (rejuvenative) for Vata. ​Warm, Cooked Foods: Favor warm, soupy, and well-cooked foods. Soups, stews, and porridges are ideal.
​Spices: Incorporate warming spices like ginger, turmeric, and cumin into your cooking. ​Millets and Rice: While millets can be slightly drying, combining them with rice is a good practice. Ensure your meals are well-oiled with ghee or sesame oil to counteract the drying nature of some grains. ​Avoid Raw, Cold, and Dry Foods: Minimize consumption of cold beverages, raw salads, and dry snacks like crackers or popcorn, as these can increase Vata.

​Supplements and Herbal Remedies

1) ​Ashwagandha churna -1tsf after food 2 times day This herb is a powerful Vata-pacifying rasayana. It can be taken with warm milk to help nourish the nervous system, muscles, and joints.

​2) Triphala Guggul 1 tab - after food 3 times a day are used for joint health.

​Sesame Seeds: Soaked sesame seeds are an excellent source of calcium and healthy fats. A handful of soaked seeds in the morning can be very beneficial.

​Specific Exercises or Lifestyle Adjustments ​Lifestyle Adjustments: ​Abhyanga (Self-Oil Massage): This is one of the most powerful Vata-pacifying practices.
​Method: Before your morning shower, warm some sesame oil (or a specific Vata-pacifying oil) and massage it all over your body with long strokes on limbs and circular motions on joints and the abdomen. ​Benefits: This practice nourishes the skin, lubricates the joints, and calms the nervous system, directly counteracting the dryness of Vata. ​Consistent Routine: Maintaining a regular daily routine (waking, eating, and sleeping at consistent times) is very grounding for Vata and can help balance the dosha.
​Stay Warm: Protect yourself from cold and wind, which are Vata-aggravating elements.
​Exercises: ​Your current routine of 30-35 minutes is good. The key for Vata is to avoid over-exertion. ​Gentle and Fluid Movements: Focus on exercises that are smooth and gentle on the joints. ​Yoga: Poses like Cat-Cow and Sun Salutations (performed slowly) can improve joint mobility.
​Swimming: This is an excellent exercise as the water provides buoyancy, reducing stress on the joints while allowing for fluid movement.
​Walking: Continue walking, but perhaps on a softer surface like grass.

​Conclusion: Joint Dryness or Vata Imbalance?

​The two are interconnected. The cracking sound is a symptom of joint dryness, and this dryness is a direct manifestation of Vata imbalance. By implementing the suggestions above—particularly the practice of Abhyanga with sesame oil and increasing healthy fats in your diet—you are directly addressing both the cause (Vata imbalance) and the symptom (joint dryness).

Is there any type of pain or stiffness along with sound?

es, but not ideal. Vata governs movement, dryness, and nerve impulses. When aggravated, it leads to: - Dry joints → cracking/popping sounds - Stiffness or sudden pain - Cold sensitivity - Fatigue after movement So while it’s common, it’s a signal—your joints are asking for lubrication, warmth, and deeper nourishment.

1.Yograj guggulu 1 tab twicce daily with water after meals 2.Dashmoolarishta 20 ml with 20 ml water twice daily after meals 3.Ksheera bala oil-massage on the knees 1-2 time daily

Even though you are vata Prakriti, your symptoms are suggesting of aggravated vata symptoms, continue the diet which is good for vata dominance but the knuckling sound which have started should not be ignored once get cbc esr crp sr calcium phosphorus vit D3 vit b12 and bone density mineral test if associated with pain get x ray both knees ap and lateral view to know the exact cause

Joint cracking sounds are often associated with Vata dosha, which governs movement and communication in the body. In your case, this could indicate an imbalance that might require attention. Individuals with a Vata constitution often experience dry skin, bloating, and yes, joint sounds - it’s not uncommon. However, the presence of additional symptoms such as discomfort or pain when these sounds occur might require further evaluation.

To address this, you need to focus on pacifying Vata and nourishing your joints. Since you’re already incorporating ghee into your diet, which is great for lubrication, you might want to complement it by adding more warming and moistening foods. Including more root vegetables like carrots, beets, and sweet potatoes can be beneficial. Also, consider adding some cooked leafy greens and whole grains in your diet; they help to balance Vata’s dryness.

Herbal supplements like Ashwagandha or Shatavari can also be taken, but consult an Ayurvedic practitioner for specific doses based on your prakriti. They support overall balance and offer nutritional support. Mahanarayan oil is an excellent option for external application—a gentle massage on your joints before a warm shower helps soothe them and improve circulation.

For lifestyle, aim to incorporate some grounding practices. Yoga asanas like Trikonasana (Triangle Pose) and Virabhadrasana (Warrior Pose) may help by enhancing joint stability. Avoid high-impact activities, which might aggravate the joints further and prefer consistency in your routine.

Stay hydrated as dehydration can heighten Vata’s dryness aspect. Liquids should be warm or at room temperature. Sip on herbal teas like ginger or licorice tea to aid digestion and joint nourishment.

If joint pain or stiffness begins to accompany the sounds, consider visiting a healthcare professional to rule out conditions like arthritis or other issues. It’s also important that you don’t ignore chronic pain or discomfort. Prevention and early intervention can keep a Vata imbalance from developing into something more severe.

Hi Dr Arshad Here (BAMS, MD), brother u are Vata Parakriti, the first guna of vata is rooksha means dryness. This dryness is not only at the level of skin. It will dry your joints fluids also All these crepitus sound is due to lack of synovial fluid in the joint

One more this vata rooksha guna also leads to constipation, kidney stones , body thining,

Treatment

To overcome dry guna of vata you have to add snigadha guna in your daily routine For ex start massage you joint with potent vata reducing oil ( ksheer bala oil) for 45 minutes

For medication start Cap ksheer Bala 101 (1 in morning with milk) Tab asthiposhak vati 1 tab twice a day

Use this for 30 days , you feel fully lubricated , no sounds
100% guaranty ( i treated a lot pt. Of same complaint) For further queries contact 9417656600

Cracking or popping sounds in joints can indeed be more common in individuals with a predominant Vata dosha, which is characterized by qualities like dryness, lightness, and mobility. While these sounds often aren’t a cause for concern, they may indicate increased Vata or dryness in the body, particularly if accompanied by any discomfort or stiffness. It’s crucial first, however, to rule out any serious joint issues, so consulting a healthcare professional for evaluation is advisable if you notice pain or swelling.

Assuming it’s a Vata imbalance, you can make some changes to help balance the dosha and support your joint health. Since Vata is dry and cold by nature, focusing on warmth and lubrication becomes essential. Including healthy fats in your diet, like you already do with ghee, is good. Adding more oils like sesame oil—which is heating and nourishing—could provide extra benefits. Moderately heating spices, such as ginger and cinnamon, can also support digestion and pacify Vata.

Considering diet, while millets and rice are good, ensure they are well-cooked and moist to avoid adding to Vata’s dryness. Root vegetables and warm, cooked meals should replace anything raw or cold. Drinking warm fluids, like herbal teas with ginger or tulsi, throughout your day can help maintain hydration and warmth within the body.

In terms of lifestyle, continuing regular exercise is beneficial, but focus on low-impact activities that aren’t jarring—like brisk walking or yoga. Specific yoga poses can be supportive, such as cat-cow stretches or the camel pose, which can help maintain joint flexibility and balance Vata energy. Post-exercise, massaging your joints with warm sesame oil can aid lubrication and reduce dryness.

Ensure adequate rest and proper sleep, as Vata benefits greatly from regular routine and relaxation. Lastly, consider an Ayurvedic supplement like Ashwagandha or Vata-balancing herbal formulations, but consult a practitioner for personalized dosage and suitability.

If any changes in your symptoms occur, or if you have underlying conditions, do seek medical advice promptly to rule out any serious issues. These steps should generally assist in providing comfort and maintaining joint health in alignment with Ayurveda.