sugar or jaggery which is better for weight loss - #38615
I am struggling with my weight, and honestly, it feels like a never-ending battle sometimes! I’ve tried various diets, signed up for a gym, but nothing seems to work effectively. Recently, a friend told me about sugar vs jaggery, saying jaggery is way better for health and could even help with weight loss. I found that really intriguing because I LOVE sweets, and cutting them out seems impossible. Like, fewer calories and better nutrients in jaggery might make it a good choice, right?? But I also read mixed things online about sugar and jaggery, like if jaggery is healthier, does it mean I can eat more of it? Have any of you faced this dilemma? I’m confused about if I should just eliminate sugar or swap it out with jaggery completely?? Ugh, it feels sooo overwhelming! And when I sometimes allow myself a treat, I find it hard to stop, especially if it’s something with jaggery in it. Could that be sabotaging my weight loss too? Anyone with personal experiences or insights about sugar or jaggery which is better for weight loss? Would love to hear your thoughts!
Shop Now in Our Store


Doctors' responses
When it comes to weight loss, understanding sugar and jaggery’s properties is crucial. In Ayurveda, sugar (white refined sugar) is considered to be more of a modern invention and is often seen as having very little, if any, nutritional benefits. It’s considered heavy, hard to digest, and can increase Kapha dosha when consumed excessively. Jaggery, on the other hand, is less refined and retains some nutritional elements like iron, magnesium, and potassium. From an Ayurvedic perspective, it’s considered less aggravating to the digestive fire or agni, which makes it a better choice.
However, one must be cautious not to assume that jaggery is a miracle substitute for weight loss. Despite its nutritional benefits compared to table sugar, jaggery still contains a high caloric density and can also lead to weight gain if consumed without moderation. The key is moderation, as replacing sugar with large amounts of jaggery might not help you lose weight.
For those who enjoy sweets, here’s a suggestion: Incorporate mild, sweet taste through natural fruits or small amounts of jaggery in your meals rather than excessively processed sweets. Consider fennel or cardamom infused warm water after meals to satiate sweet cravings in a healthy way. To strengthen your digestion, include spices like ginger and turmeric in your diet, as they can help to balance Kapha and Pitta in your body.
It’s beneficial to understand one’s prakriti, or body constitution. Those with dominant Kapha should be particularly mindful of sweets as they tend to accumulate weight more easily. Opting for sattvic foods—fresh, whole, and unprocessed—is best. Ayurveda emphasizes mindful eating practices, so paying attention to your hunger cues and portion sizes is essential.
Remember, achieving balance in lifestyle and diet goes beyond just choosing between sugar and jaggery. Combining these with regular physical exercise appropriate for your body type, like brisk walking, yoga, or cycling, will aid in maintaining your healthy weight. If you find difficulty in controlling sweet cravings, there might be root imbalances that need attention, so working with an Ayruvedic practitioner might be useful.
Adjusting your lifestyle with mindful eating and lifestyle habits can often be more effective than merely switching ingredients. Don’t self-sabotage by overindulging in jaggery thinking it’s a weight-loss aid. It’s essential to consume it in moderation and pay attention to how your body responds to different foods.

100% Anonymous
600+ certified Ayurvedic experts. No sign-up.
About our doctors
Only qualified ayurvedic doctors who have confirmed the availability of medical education and other certificates of medical practice consult on our service. You can check the qualification confirmation in the doctor's profile.
