Ask Ayurveda

FREE! Ask Ayurvedic Doctors 24/7

Get expert answers from certified doctors anytime

Fast responses
1000+ verified doctors
/
/
/
Hyderabad Fish Treatment
Respiratory Disorders
Consultation #6978
1 year ago
1,063

Hyderabad Fish Treatment - #6978

Isaac
FREE

My cousin, who has asthma, was recently talking about the Hyderabad fish treatment. Apparently, it’s some kind of traditional remedy where you swallow live fish with herbal paste to help with respiratory problems. Has anyone here tried the Hyderabad fish treatment, or knows someone who has? I’m curious if this treatment is really effective. Does it actually help reduce asthma symptoms, or is it just a popular belief? Also, is the Hyderabad fish treatment safe, or are there risks involved with swallowing live fish? How long do the effects of the Hyderabad fish treatment last, and do you need to keep going back for it? My cousin is thinking of traveling to Hyderabad specifically for this, but I’m not sure if it’s worth the effort. If anyone has firsthand experience or knows more about how the Hyderabad fish treatment works, please share!

Consultation is closed

Doctors' responses

Dr. Ravi Chandra Rushi
Master of Surgery in Ayurveda
1 year ago
5

The Hyderabad fish treatment is a traditional remedy for asthma that involves swallowing a live fish smeared with herbal paste. This treatment is primarily found in certain Ayurvedic and folk medicine practices in the Hyderabad region, and while some claim it helps with asthma symptoms by improving breathing and reducing inflammation, there is limited scientific evidence to support its effectiveness.

The fish is believed to carry certain medicinal properties when combined with the paste, which is made from herbs known in Ayurveda to benefit respiratory health. However, the practice has raised concerns due to safety risks, particularly the risks of swallowing live fish. Potential dangers include choking, aspiration pneumonia, or allergic reactions to the fish itself, making it a risky procedure for some people.

The treatment’s long-term benefits are not well-documented, and many people report only temporary relief. Whether or not your cousin needs to return for repeated treatments depends on individual responses, but it’s important to consult with a healthcare professional before trying such alternative treatments. If your cousin is interested, it might be beneficial to consider less invasive Ayurvedic remedies that have a more established safety record for asthma management, such as herbal teas (e.g., Tulsi or Vasaka) and breathing exercises like pranayama.

Given the potential health risks, it’s advisable to research thoroughly and consult with a medical professional before seeking out this treatment.

16058 answered questions
33% best answers
Accepted response

0 replies
Dr. Sara Garg
Bachelor of Ayurvedic Medicine and Surgery
1 year ago
5

The “Hyderabad fish treatment” you’re referring to seems to be part of a traditional remedy used for respiratory issues, including asthma, though it is quite unconventional. This treatment generally involves swallowing live fish that are coated in a herbal paste, believed to provide medicinal benefits. While there are anecdotal accounts suggesting that some individuals have found relief from symptoms like asthma through this treatment, there is limited scientific evidence supporting its efficacy.

Regarding safety, there are significant risks involved in swallowing live fish, including potential choking hazards, infections, or allergic reactions to the fish or herbs used. The practice also lacks clinical validation, which raises concerns about its overall safety and effectiveness. As for the duration of its effects, it appears that the results may vary from person to person, and many individuals reportedly require repeated sessions to maintain any benefits.

If your cousin is seriously considering this treatment, it is essential to approach it with caution. Consulting with a qualified medical professional, particularly one knowledgeable about both conventional and traditional treatments, would be wise. It’s also important to consider safer, more evidence-backed therapies for asthma management, such as Ayurvedic herbs (like Tulsi and Vasaka) or prescribed asthma medications.

13290 answered questions
28% best answers

0 replies
Dr. Snehal Vidhate
Bachelor of Ayurvedic Medicine and Surgery
1 year ago
5

Ah, the Hyderabad fish treatment, it stirs quite a bit of attention! It’s indeed a traditional practice called ‘Goud treatment’, organized by a family of healers known as the Bathini Goud brothers. The treatment involves swallowing a live murrel fish stuffed with a herbal paste. It’s touted to help with asthma, and thousands flock to Hyderabad annually seeking relief. But, the effectiveness is really hard to pin down – it’s not exactly backed by science in the way modern medicine would be.

Now, regarding effectiveness – while there are testimonials claiming substantial ease in breathing post-treatment, it’s very much an anecdotal thing. It means it may work for some, and not at all for others. Plus, improvement in symptoms could be temporary, needing yearly repetitions.

As for safety, it’s kinda tricky. Swallowing a live fish could pose several risks, from choking hazards to possible allergic reactions. The herbal ingredients also don’t come with any KNOWN side effects, but without controlled studies, one can’t be sure. There’s also potential hygiene concerns, considering the mass gatherings when it’s administered.

For your cousin, I’d say it’s critical to weigh the potential benefits against these risks. If he’s someone who’s had trouble managing asthma with conventional treatments, and has the opportunity and curiosity to try something different, maybe it’s worth a shot. But if he’s seeking a guaranteed solution, it might not be the thing.

Ultimately, for anyone considering it, it’s essential to consult with a healthcare professional beforehand. It would be wise to keep realistic expectations and ensure it’s a well-informed choice rather than a leap of faith. The appeal of traditional remedies can be strong, but understanding the whole picture can guide better decisions!

12035 answered questions
28% best answers

0 replies

The treatment course was sent to the patient's private messages.


What to do for persistent coughing and shortness of breath all day long?
How to treat thick phlegm in my chest that won't go away after using ginger, tulsi, and licorice root?
Severe Breathing Problems and Wheezing
Can I take Thuthvalai kasha yam for cold, sneezing, and throat infection, and how often should I take it?
Can I use Vasaristha syrup while taking allopathic medicine for heart and lung issues?
Can I use standardized extract of Ephedra Gerardiana for bronchitis instead of tea?
What are some Ayurvedic remedies for my toddler's dry cough and cold with sneezing and wheezing?
How to treat idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis in a patient with lupus and heart surgery history?
What to do for my 65-year-old mother who has shortness of breath without exertion and swelling after taking medication?
Can I stop giving my 4-year-old child Septilin syrup if his cough is getting worse and he feels restless?
What to do for persistent mucus in the throat every morning without cough?
How to treat long-term sinus issues with symptoms like fever, shortness of breath, and frequent sneezing?
What is the main cause of mucus in the throat according to Ayurveda?
How to get rid of phlegm from the body using fenugreek and amla powder?
How to get rid of phlegm from the body with methi and amla powder?
How Do I Get Rid of Phlegm and Tight Chest?
asthma and heart palpitations
How to treat persistent cough and chest congestion after COVID for 2 months?
Can I eat cooked rice while having fever, cold, and dry cough with throat irritation?
What food and remedies can I give my 1 year and 11 months old daughter for her recurring cough and chest congestion?
What happens after 5 years of asthma and can eating 2 bananas daily cure it in a month?
Flu Symptoms and Loss of Taste
How to prepare jimson weed for asthma steaming and should I inhale smoke or steam?
Can I take Srikara Amodini tablets for congestion and phlegm in throat and chest from acid reflux?
How to treat recurrent cold and runny nose in my 6-year-old daughter?
How to give Jufex Forte syrup to my 3-year-old child for congestion, cold, and cough?
What to do for excessive mucus in the chest and throat after eating and drinking water?
Can I use half karakayi for dry cough relief during my first trimester?
Can Laxmivilas Ras Help My Child's Asthma Cough?
Can I use Swas Kas Chintamani Ras for my bronchitis?
How to treat continuous rib pain in my 86-year-old mother with weak muscles and respiratory failure?
How to treat asthma and breathing problems with Ayurvedic medicine?
What to do for persistent cold and loss of appetite for a year?
How to treat a dry cough that has lasted for 15 days?
My Son's Persistent Nasal Block and Sinusitis Issues
What to do if I have breathing issues and gallbladder stones after taking prescribed medications?
How to remove phlegm quickly and easily? What are effective methods for eliminating mucus?
How to treat my 4-year-old daughter's persistent cough and cold with allergies for the past year?
Can Plants Help Manage My Asthma?
How to treat persistent dry cough with throat irritation and wheezing in a 68-year-old male smoker?
How to treat my 7-year-old son's persistent cough and asthma despite using an inhaler?
Best Ayurvedic Treatment for Thick Phlegm in Respiratory Passage
How to treat long-lasting cold and cough with asthma and digestion issues?
chronic chest congestion and cough
How to treat persistent chest infections and phlegm that won't clear with Ayurveda?
How to treat heaviness and weight gain from Ayurvedic medicine while managing asthma and cough?
How to completely eliminate sinus and asthma issues?
What to do if my 56-year-old brother is coughing up blood for two weeks?
What to do for persistent cough and chest itching lasting four months after drinking cold water?
Can Ayurveda help my husband recover from ILD cysts and low oxygen levels?
What does a lung pressure of 30 and a saas test result of 68.2 indicate?
Can I use Ayurvedic herbs like Safed Musli and Ashwagandha for weight gain while treating a lung fungal infection with Itraconazole?
How to use Khadirarishta and other Ayurvedic medicines for cough and mucus?
Can I give Asitopaladi to my 2-year-old daughter for her sore throat, fever, and runny nose, and what is the correct dose?
What to do for persistent cough, body aches, and difficulty sleeping at night?
Can I use Somlata for asthma treatment after heart stenting at age 75?
How to improve lung health and reduce inhaler dependency after asthma attack in a postpartum woman?
chronic cough and throat infection
How Did I Cure My Asthma Naturally?
Can I use Vasaristha syrup along with allopathic medicines for lung infection and breathing issues?
How to use Rasani churna for stress relief with sinus problems and headaches?
What to do for persistent cough and white sputum with airway stenosis and lung collapse?
What to do for persistent cough and difficulty breathing for 15 days?
How to treat my 9-year-old son's asthma and chest congestion during summer?
How to relieve severe sore throat and nasal congestion after fever in a 22-year-old female?
What to do if I can't feel one lung and have no appetite or energy after masturbation?
What is the Ayurvedic treatment for my 6-year-old daughter with frequent cold and runny nose?
hoarse voice and breathlessness
How to clear mucus cough in my 4-year-old after typhoid and frequent cold?
What to do for my 72-year-old wife who has been coughing up phlegm for over six months?
How long should I practice Brahmacharya to cure my asthma and reduce nightfall?
How to treat breathing difficulties caused by Pitta imbalance?
Can Ashwagandha help with severe cold and wheezing in an 84-year-old?
What to do for asthma symptoms after chest surgery and weight gain?
How to treat chest congestion causing occasional breathing problems?
What to do for a sore throat with fever and green mucus in an adult?
What to do for cough and throat pain with phlegm and runny nose?
How to use Chawarka for cold, cough, phlegm, and acidity in a 29-year-old?
What to do for a persistent cough with wheezing and phlegm but no breathlessness?
Managing Asthma for a Better Quality of Life
What is the best medicine for asthma if I haven't seen any change after 3 months?
What to do for constant cold and fatigue with itching in ears and eyes?
Seeking Relief from Post-Nasal Drip and Digestive Issues
How to get rid of a constant cough after eating with throat itchiness?
Can I take Septilin tablet for wet cough and body ache after 2 days of symptoms?
How to treat excessive phlegm in the throat for an elderly man living in Canada?
How to treat a sore throat and cough in an adult with no improvement after 2 days of Dabur Laxmi Villas Ras and Dabur Adulsa?
How to treat breathing problems and skin issues after taking ashwagandha at 40 years old?
Can I use Vaturva while taking Salbutamol and Trelegy Ellipta for COPD?
Persistent Cough with Blood in Phlegm
What to do for headaches that start in the sun and improve with sleep and coffee for an 18-year-old male?
Can I use Krimi Ghanvati for a long time to manage my asthma and heaviness in the diaphragm area?
How to treat snoring caused by moderate OSA and sinus issues?
Can I give my baby Paripathadi Kadha after lung infection?
What to do if I have a persistent headache after drinking sugarcane juice?
What to do for breathing issues and persistent coughing in a 58-year-old smoker?
How to manage asthma and shortness of breath after eating roti with raw tomatoes?
How to use Chandraamrit Ras for asthma at age 35 and what are its side effects?
How to treat my 72-year-old mother’s asthma and dry cough with diabetes?
How to treat my 6-year-old daughter’s recurring cold and runny nose with Ayurveda?

Latest reviews

Client_ecfa68
6 days ago
Bahut hi knowledgeable doctor, gastric problem ka permanent solution mila.
Bahut hi knowledgeable doctor, gastric problem ka permanent solution mila.
Avery
12 days ago
This answer was super helpful and put my mind at ease. Appreciated the detailed and practical advice on what to actually try. Feeling more informed! Thumbs up!
This answer was super helpful and put my mind at ease. Appreciated the detailed and practical advice on what to actually try. Feeling more informed! Thumbs up!
Client_0a5cw8
13 days ago
very good, informative, detailed explanation and support is amazing. thanks.
very good, informative, detailed explanation and support is amazing. thanks.
Client_0a5cw8
13 days ago
informative, clear and intelligent. one of the best in ask ayurveda. thank you for all the help.
informative, clear and intelligent. one of the best in ask ayurveda. thank you for all the help.